American Idiot Review (lyrics, lead singer, drum, instrumental, pop)

Rainard Jalen · 07-03-2008, 01:05 PM

dookie was a pretty good pop punk album which i certainly enjoyed at the time of its coming out. i don't think american idiot is a good album. some of the songs might be catchy, but catchy does not equate to good. millions of songs are catchy in an irritating way, and that's exactly what i think of greenday's more recent material.

Alfred · 07-03-2008, 04:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JayJamJah

Alfred your a reasonable guy, one who evens like U2, and I'll give you that because despite my disdain for them, I realize different strokes for different folks, what's your opinion?

Do you think people who rip Green Day do so more because they actually don't like them or because they are bitter they got so big while other seemingly as or more deserving acts did not?

I dunno, really, I can enjoy a Green Day song, even an American Idiot one (if I'm in a good mood), but, idk, there's something about it that, is kind of phony. I don't hate Green Day, but I don't like them.

I used to be in love with them when American Idiot came out though. But I was what, 10? It might be an outgrowing thing too. I gave up Sum 41 recently too. Kinda childish.

I love the stuff from Dookie and before though. 1000 Hours is easily my favorite song my them.

I think a lot of people who rip on them have a personal bias.

monoxide_child_1 · 07-05-2008, 10:02 PM

American Idiot was basiclly them slapping themselves in the face. Everybody loved and aknowledged them for their old ways of playing, lyrical content, and output, but it seemed with this new album that they entirely changed everything about themselves, their no longer a chill music group you can sit around and smoke weed to, like they once were, they changed their whole persona just to fit back into the musical industry. which to me is the biggest shame an artist can do. MUSIC FIRST! if a record wont sign you because you dont fit into the new modern sound, then screw them and go somewhere else. but dont change to fit in.

JayJamJah · 07-06-2008, 08:29 AM

If anything I would say the opposite, I think American idiot was more of a nod to the old way of making music. The Rock Opera tracks, the themed album, prior to that they just made a lot of poppy pseudo-punk songs, that sounded great live, but were more commercial and radio-friendly.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

07-03-2008, 01:05 PM
Rainard Jalen Music Addict Join Date: Aug 2006 Posts: 1,719	dookie was a pretty good pop punk album which i certainly enjoyed at the time of its coming out. i don't think american idiot is a good album. some of the songs might be catchy, but catchy does not equate to good. millions of songs are catchy in an irritating way, and that's exactly what i think of greenday's more recent material.

07-05-2008, 10:02 PM
monoxide_child_1 Groupie Join Date: Jul 2008 Location: in a hole Posts: 10	American Idiot was basiclly them slapping themselves in the face. Everybody loved and aknowledged them for their old ways of playing, lyrical content, and output, but it seemed with this new album that they entirely changed everything about themselves, their no longer a chill music group you can sit around and smoke weed to, like they once were, they changed their whole persona just to fit back into the musical industry. which to me is the biggest shame an artist can do. MUSIC FIRST! if a record wont sign you because you dont fit into the new modern sound, then screw them and go somewhere else. but dont change to fit in. __________________ "f*ck the system, fight the system, rise against them"

07-06-2008, 08:29 AM
JayJamJah Revisonists History Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: The end of the Earth Posts: 1,289	If anything I would say the opposite, I think American idiot was more of a nod to the old way of making music. The Rock Opera tracks, the themed album, prior to that they just made a lot of poppy pseudo-punk songs, that sounded great live, but were more commercial and radio-friendly.