Jimmy vs. Jimi (hendrix, quote)

[stymie]

hendrix.

it's not even close.

s

[Kashmir86]

Originally Posted by stymie

hendrix.

it's not even close.

s

yeah jimmy page sure sucks huh. maybe you should put a supporting argument in with your post if your gonna say somethin like that

[stymie]

Originally Posted by Kashmir86

yeah jimmy page sure sucks huh. maybe you should put a supporting argument in with your post if your gonna say somethin like that

never was it intimated that jimmy page sucks...plus i didn't realize justification was needed for opinion but....i think hendrix is/was head and shoulders above 'any' modern rock guitarist. he broke trail for everyone. no one before, nor since has had the impact on the electric guitar and how it's used in rock and roll like jimi hendrix.

i'll not belittle jimmy page or any other player. i happen to be a fan more for led zepp than page though. there's a bit of the supporting argument needed then. band vs. solo. outside the context of the band, will page's legacy endure as hendrix's has...and will no doubt continue to? i don't think so. hendrix will affect generations. without zeppelin, i don't think the same can be said of page.

s

[holdfasthope]

Hendrix is extremly over-rated. it angers me.

[JohnnyRamone]

Originally Posted by Kashmir86

i agree with that exept i prefer pages soloing better, but i realize that's personal preference, i just think that live especially hendrix uses the tremelo a bit excessive at times, and i just like the versatility of pages solos so he wins in my opinion. i also enjoy the length of his solos when playing live. i realize as well that page may get more credit than hendrix for the fact he had on hell of a band backing him up, everyone was awesome at what they did, where hendrix had only 2 others that were good musicians but nowhere near jonesy, plant, and bonzo. i give credit where credit is due, and hendrix was one hell of a musician, but as for solely voting for best guitarist, i go for page.

yeah,the solo's are kind of my opinion there I like hendrix's use w/ the wah wah so much though!

[bungalowbill357]

Originally Posted by Kashmir86

yeah jimmy page sure sucks huh. maybe you should put a supporting argument in with your post if your gonna say somethin like that

Your one to talk.
How about you put a good supporting argument.
Rap sure sucks huh...

[thedude01]

Originally Posted by bungalowbill357

Your one to talk.
How about you put a good supporting argument.
Rap sure sucks huh...

Funny stuff and whoever said that any new Raps good theres a foram for that go to your 'Soul' bros. not to be racest i like some old rap that had soul

[boo boo]

Originally Posted by holdfasthope

Hendrix is extremly over-rated. it angers me.

Overrated?... Maybe, but hes still the greatest.

[Kashmir86]

Originally Posted by bungalowbill357

Your one to talk.
How about you put a good supporting argument.
Rap sure sucks huh...

why, so that you and misfitspunk can argue back and forth with me? Is this your only goal in life to start ****? Your pathetic. Anyways back on topic i agree that hendrix is overrated. The way I see it is: Great guitar player + Early death = #1. I would like to see what people would be sayin if page had an early death, and hendrix lasted as long as page in the band, I have a feeling it would totally be the other way around. Early death usually leads to much more recoginition, e.g. Cobain, Dimebag, etc.

[Music Man]

Originally Posted by stymie

hendrix. it's not even close.

Actually, it's very close.

I'm a huge Hendrix fan, but Jimmy Page is right up there with him.