Sabgoat

i nevre liekd paul either.. he seemed to always try and take all of the atention.. and took more cerdit then he should have.. because he really was not that great in my eyes..

Wild7Dustr

Well, atleast he didn't "ruin" The Beatles, ya see?He was great with The Beatles while other bands might be judged differently by their (our) own opinions!!!I'd still have to say that any Beatle fan has to somewhat like him and respect him for his contribution to (atleast) that band (Beatles)!!!

Sabgoat

you say "ruin" like john did... when he never

Urban Hatemonger

Ringo was doing that long before Yoko Ono turned up

__________________

Sabgoat

good poin!

i don't blame yoko at all really. cause john has his own brains to think with. he made his own choices.

bungalowbill357

Please, elaborate.
Because I disagree.
If one single thing could be attributed to the breakup of the Beatles.
It was quarrels between Paul and, all the other Beatles.
By White Album, and even towards the end of the Mystery Tour sessions, Paul played every instrument on every track that he had written.
He felt that all of the others just werent able to play their parts right.
He did Drums, Guitar and Bass, on almost every song he wrote.
This, understandably pissed off the other members.
Pauls arguing and bashing the other members is most notable on the Let It Be film. And if you have the studio tracks, tou can clearly hear him insult George's guitar playing.
Many times he and George got into arguments.
Which caused George to leave the band.
John was already planning on leaving because he was sick of Pauls insistence that everything be absolutely perfect and he was tired of Paul acting like the "leader" of the band.
Before John made his announcement to leave, Ringo left because he felt "left out"
And Paul ended it just before John decided to make the final "goodbye" to the band

Urban Hatemonger

Oh come on this isn`t some huge debate , even the band themselves took the piss out of his contribution.

__________________

boo boo

He didnt make much of a contrebution as far as songwriting is concerned, but i dont see how that means he "ruined" The Beatles, thats just silly.

__________________
http://www.progarchives.com/

boo boo

Anyway its a tie between John and Paul but anyone who says "John ****s all over Paul" is just giving John the sympathy vote, their biggest album ever was Sgt Pepper, Lennon made little contrebution to more than 3 songs, most of the best songs off The White Album were from Paul, though John did have Julia and Sexy Sadie.

__________________
http://www.progarchives.com/

Urban Hatemonger

I was being silly , call it an overreaction to Yellow Submarine *shudder*

__________________