dude are the crits on this forum lame or what?
lol
#1 i liked the second line most of all... although the imagery is good throughout the piece, i think, judging by your caliber of writing, that just about everything other than the second line could use a bit of a tweak. Particularly the first and last lines... which didnt make as much of a bang as i would have expected...
#2 I have few problems with this... its a wonderful concept, and though almost seeming cliche, it comes across well. Again the first and last parts of the piece, work well with the piece, but come across a little weak on their own. The only other major thing is that shining eyes is a bit overused maybe a tweak... great piece
#3 the second and final lines are quite good... the rest seems to be a bit out of place. although it doesnt seem to be in keeping with the rest of your pieces, i'd love to see these pieces expanded, even by one or two lines. It somehow seems a waste to leave such a visual concept with so little imagery.
#4 i like this piece alot, except for the ending... i really dont wanna sound harsh, but man, it killed it. I would love to see you carry on the cilestial (spelling?) theme you had going on, or atleast make something less cliche.
#5 this is definately my least favourite of them all. I LOVE the concept... but you really ruined it for me with the second, and final 2 lines. I thought the second was just a bit crude, especially when coupled with a relatively angelic image. I would have liked to see you carry on the more angelic feel of the piece until the end, sorta relate the high to thinking ones' self an angel (or more prominant religous figures, the J bomb?). I disliked the last two lines mainly because it killed the angelic vibe i was getting. I definately think its a good ending to the little narrative youve got going on, but agian, a bit crude for the vibe im getting...
do you think you could crit my song Arsonist at My Doorstep? id really like to see what you think about it
|