The question is... does this:-
Quote:
Originally Posted by mark1990celtic1888
... Travis, the Frattelis, the View have showed that Scotland’s not only famous for deep fried marsbars and the animal that treks across the highlands. ...
|
Warrrant this:-
Quote:
Originally Posted by jackhammer
Unfortunately a review with the names: TRAVIS, THE FRATELLIS and THE VIEW loses immediate credibility.
|
bit harsh?
Regardless of what was said between mark and jackhammer in PM it was said in a public forum where people such as I (a biffy clyro and review fan) have to read it.
Even though everyone is (pretty much) allowed to share their opinion there are some comments that will create a backlash and some that won't, it's having the hindsight to see it coming and the conviction to justify it that will stop people thinking you're a tosser.
Even though nothing negative was said about BC it was an incredibly narrowminded/unfunny comment to add. All it accomplished was to highlight how narrowminded jackhammer is.
I don't know jackhammer from a bar of soap but on first impressions I know that from now on whenever I read a comment made my him I shall think back to the narrowminded comment he made in the BC: puzzle thread, it that too harsh?
Personally I think the review was outstanding and I feel that the only credibility that was lost in this thread was that of jackhammers.
But hey thats just my opinion.
P.s. can I also add another jackhammer quote from another thread
musicbanter.com/indie-alternative/28634-teenage-fanclub-2.html
Quote:
|
The comp sounds tasty Mr Nic. Keep contributing as quality posters help the rep of the site.
|
Take some of your own advice.