Lisnaholic

Yes, I remember, right at the beginning of this thread you made it clear that you were talking about the music, not supporting or condoning the man, which is a commendable distinction to make.

You`re right, as well, the Beach Boys shouldn`t have recorded his songs without crediting him as composer, but wasn`t it only ever the one song ? I`m not really convinced that Manson was quite the victim that you paint him out to be. After all, Dennis Wilson let the Manson Family use his home. Did Wilson really promise, as well, to make a musical career for Manson, or did he just promise to give the guy a try out and access to one of the most sought-after recording studios of the time ?

Yes, the Manson groupies probably made quite an impact on Dennis Wilson ( although I imagine that any one of the Beach Boys could probably have picked up a groupie in their own right if they felt so inclined).
Anyway, if you`re interested, here are a couple of quotes from Ed Sanders` The Family about what was apparently going on at the time:

* " Returning from a recording session at 3 a.m.,Wilson discovered Manson and about twenty nubile caressing females in his living room. A friendship developed, and the Manson group underwent a multi-month mooch on Wilson`s resources that drained him of about $100,000."
* " There was one incident when M pulled a knife on Wilson, held it to his throat and said, " What would you do if I killed you? " Wilson reportedly just shrugged and said, " Do it !" and M lowered the blade."
* " When the single ( Cotton Fields/Never Learn Not To Love ) was released, it did not sell so well. As payment for the song Manson evidently got some cash and a BSA motorcycle."
* "Things got weird for Manson (at Wilson`s house). The Family had pretty much devoured the scene. Wilson`s fabulous rock and roll wardrobe became community property and Manson gave away Wilson`s gold records. This was evidently distressing to Wilson, who abandoned ship and moved to a house near the beach. Shortly thereafter, Dennis Wilson`s manager threw Manson and crew off the property."

Ska Lagos Jew Sun Ra

Well, he had to have known Manson was an ex con. It's foolish to invite an ex con into your house just for an orgy or two. Besides, if Wilson didn't expect Manson to expect him to give him a chance. Why did Manson share his demo with Wilson? Seems very odd thing to do.

__________________
Al Pacino = God

Lisnaholic

That`s true, Wilson was pretty being naive and must`ve understood that Manson was hoping for a big musical breakthrough. I wonder how often that happens, that an aspiring musician has his demo ideas ripped off ?
Well, I guess we`ll never know what was going on in those guys heads at the time, and if the rumours about Dennis Wilson`s drug intake are true, he probably didn`t know either !

Stone Birds

there are basically 2 things that cause someone to be like this:
Psychology and Sociology
in fact a lot of times when thinking about these 2 factors when relating them to a killer or a rapist i almost feel sorry for them because the fact is there was obviously something even possibly a minor detail in their childhood that helped lead them to this. i think something some people forget is that everyone was a baby every one was a kid and everyone was once a teenager, and generally it's events when you're a kid and teenager that cause you to become this way and interruption in the developmental process. and how your mind is developed affects how it works, process and reacts.

but i agree that his music is very good

__________________

[Link removed by mod, no advertising] ... Damn those mods are always gettin ya :)

Howard the Duck

i love Never Learnt Not to Love (Cease to Exist)

Ska Lagos Jew Sun Ra

Charles Manson was just released from prison at the time he started his family. Prior to that he literally spent more of his life in prison than free. Many say he actually likes, and feels comfortable in prison because it's where he basically grew up.

__________________
Al Pacino = God

Freebase Dali

I was hoping there'd be a Charlie Manson thread here.
I've recently taken quite a liking to this song of his:

__________________

Frownland

Oh yes, the good Manson. I really like LIE as a whole, but I haven't checked out any of his other works.

__________________

Studies show that when a given norm is changed in the face of the unchanging, the remaining contradictions will parallel the truth.

Stephen

Would his music have deserved or received any attention if he wasn't already famous for being psycho?

Frownland

I wonder what Manson's story would be if he achieved critical acclaim in the music world and hence did not instigate any violence, or if his achievement wouldn't hinder his psychopathy.

__________________

Studies show that when a given norm is changed in the face of the unchanging, the remaining contradictions will parallel the truth.