littlemouse

*etc, (will edit when I've gathered enough posts)
Curious to hear some of MB's opinions on this topic.
Is it ever "excusable" for an artist to make such a song? Does it bring down the quality of the rest of their work?
When is it making a social statement through a racist/sexist...etc narrator and when isn't it? Ex: The Rolling Stones' "Brown Sugar."
What about the disparity in calling out violence & sexism in "gangsta rap" compared to bands like Guns N Roses (especially blaming increased violence on rap)?
What about songs like the Violent Femmes' "Black Girls" ?
I'm not too sure about any of this, it's something I started thinking about recently after reading a post at "stuff white people do" titled "listen to racist music" about "Brown Sugar." So, thoughts?
Sorry, first thread, lmk if I placed it wrong?

__________________

Trollheart

Very good first thread, and an intriguing question. I'm not familiar with gangsta rap, hip-hop or any of the other genres who seem to be more predisposed towards using racism or sexism in their lyrics, but I would just offer that it's not a new thing (as you point out): bands have been doing it for years --- which doesn't necessarily make it right --- and rock and metal would be another big culprit. I mean, not too many prog rock songs refer to "Girls with big tits" or whatever, unless you extend sexism to speciesism, in which case those guys REALLY have it in for dragons!

Gotta think about this more, will post again. I'm sure there'll be plenty of conflicting replies.

Well done: exactly what we need in a thread: intelligent, well thought-out, bound to create debate and interesting.

And not, to my knowledge, done here before...

__________________
Trollheart: Signature-free since April 2018

Janszoon

I think a lot of the time those accusations come from people failing to understand that a work of art dealing with offensive subject matter is not the same that as endorsing it.

__________________
A Night in the Life of the Invisible Man

Time & Place

25 Albums You Should Hear Before the Moon Crashes into the Earth and We All Die

last.fm

musicsbiggestfan

What about the bands who are in fact racist, such as any white power groups.

musicsbiggestfan

There is a radio station online for aryan radio.

jackhammer

I become equally annoyed when it's 'etc' and not 'ect'

__________________

hip hop bunny hop

I don't care and don't see it as any different than a band preaching some other moral/political stance.

__________________
Have mercy on the poor.

CanwllCorfe

For racism the three things that come to mind are Nazi Punk, National Socialist Black Metal, and good ol' Johnny Rebel.







I obviously don't agree with it, but they're free to make music about whatever they feel like.

__________________
Your eyes were never yet let in to see the majesty and riches of the mind, but dwell in darkness; for your God is blind.

Forward To Death

Freedom of speech, and also artistic purposes would have to make me say that it doesn't have a negative impact. I think that everyone should look at Slayer, a band that does songs about the Holocaust and "blasphemous" material. Lombardo is a devout catholic. It's just music, and I think you have to approach it with an open mind.

Forward To Death

David Alan Coe, who has done his fair share of racist music, actually has had black musicians, and I believe he has denied being racist.