Trollheart's Listening List 2015/2016

Trollheart · 12-27-2016, 10:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Batlord

Yeah that was a joke. He doesn't actually like your writing.

I assumed as much. Mine was a double joke.

**Frownland** · 12-27-2016, 10:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Batlord

Yeah that was a joke. He doesn't actually like your writing.

It's true that I don't like his writing style, but he reviews well and gives you a good sense of the music itself sounds like, which is actually pretty admirable given how little TH knows about music (see: melody/harmony confusion).

The Batlord · 12-27-2016, 10:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Frownland

It's true that I don't like his writing style, but he reviews well and gives you a good sense of the music itself sounds like, which is actually pretty admirable given how little TH knows about music (see: melody/harmony confusion).

That was a top 10 TH moment.

Trollheart · 12-27-2016, 10:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Frownland

It's true that I don't like his writing style, but he reviews well and gives you a good sense of the music itself sounds like, which is actually pretty admirable given how little TH knows about music (see: melody/harmony confusion).

I've always admitted, not being a musician, I know very little about the composition of music, so I try to use my overly flowery prose style to describe the music as best I can: "rippling piano", "hard guitar", "soaring vocals" etc. I just do the best I can. It's actually not that easy.

**Frownland** · 12-27-2016, 10:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Trollheart

I've always admitted, not being a musician, I know very little about the composition of music, so I try to use my overly flowery prose style to describe the music as best I can: "rippling piano", "hard guitar", "soaring vocals" etc. I just do the best I can. It's actually not that easy.

Exactly, and you do it well.

Compliment quota of 2017 has already been filled. Damn.

The Batlord · 12-27-2016, 10:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Trollheart

I've always admitted, not being a musician, I know very little about the composition of music, so I try to use my overly flowery prose style to describe the music as best I can: "rippling piano", "hard guitar", "soaring vocals" etc. I just do the best I can. It's actually not that easy.

One thing I would say is that the adjectives you use are often overused, both by you and others, so that they often sound like cliches. It works, but sometimes it's goofy.

Trollheart · 12-27-2016, 11:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Batlord

One thing I would say is that the adjectives you use are often overused, both by you and others, so that they often sound like cliches. It works, but sometimes it's goofy.

I'm fully aware of that, but it's part of my charm.

Also, it's hard to keep coming up with new ways to describe sounds. "Rippling", "Tinkling", "Bubbling" ... there are only so many ways you can write these things. At least they're evocative.

Trollheart · 12-29-2016, 04:47 PM

Note: It's come to my notice that the colour I use for "Like" (Orange or even DarkOrange) is a little harsh, so I'm changing it now. Here, and in "Love or Hate?", or anywhere else I use my marking system, "Like" will now be indicated by this colour.

Title: Isla de Muerta
Artiste: Ten
Year 2015
Nationality: British
Genre: Melodic Rock/AOR
Rank: High Priest
12

Expectations: I don't know: I'm a huge fan of this widely unregarded band, yet their recent releases have generally failed to instil in me the fire and passion that their earlier material did. In fact, the last Ten album I could call really great was 2005's The Twilight Chronicles, and while they did impress with 2012's Heresy and Creed, even then I was reaching a little. I've yet to hear the previous year's Albion, though what I've heard from it has given me hope that they may have regained the sparkle that characterised albums such as Return to Evermore, Babylon and Far Beyond the World. Will this, their latest, continue that upward trend? I see the succession of silly covers goes on; these guys don't do themselves any favours with their choice of cover art. The older albums were blander in general, but at least they didn't make you want to roll your eyes. Ah well, on we go.

]1. Buccaneers/Dead men tell no tales: This is the second album, but the first I've heard, to feature a quad-guitar attack, with Gary Hughes and John Halliwell backed up now by two “new” guys (they joined for the previous album, so they're new to me at this point), Steve Grocott and Dann Rosingana. The instrumental beginning is certainly nothing to get excited about, typical Ten instrumental and as it happens mostly driven on keys. They're what usher in the first actual track too; have to say it sounds a lot like “Albion born” off the previous album. Meh, for a band with four guitars to draw on they don't seem to capitalise on this, not so far anyway. A decent song, but it's hardly blowing me away or making me think of classic Ten. All told, fairly weak opener.
2. Revolution: Kind of an almost industrial sound to this, and maybe they're about to use the power of multi-guitars here? Well, if anything this reminds me of Gary Hughes's solo work on the double concept album Once and Future King. Better than the opener though, kicks a little life into proceedings. I can hear the guitars getting into it now.
3. Acquiesce: This has a good sense of fun and almost poppy rock to it, certainly more in the AOR than hard rock vein. Good keyboard runs and some decent guitar; kind of a sense almost of seventies rock too. First decent proper guitar solo here. No idea who's playing it though.
4. The Dragon and Saint George: This track I already reviewed when I looked at the EP of the same name, so if you want to know about it check that review out.
5. Intensify: Now this sounds very familiar: sort of reminds me of “Evil's on top of the world”. Good hook in the chorus though. Probably one of the best so far, which, given that it sounds so much like a previous song, is not really good. Still, I guess I'll take what I can get at this point. Sigh. It never used to be like this.
6. This love: Oh here we go! If there's one thing Gary and Ten do well it's ballads, and here's the first, and it does not disappoint. Almost worth the price of the album by itself. It has everything: great piano line, soft synth, the trademark Ten vocal harmonies and I assume ... yes, there it is, a soaring guitar solo. Formulaic, I guess, but I love Ten ballads, and their albums would not be the same without at least one. Oh, that has cheered me up. Now let's see if we can keep this mood, although...
7. Karnak/The Valley of the Kings: Ten do tend to use a lot of Egyptian motifs in their lyrics, and I have to be honest, it's getting a little tiresome. The instrumental that precedes the track is just what you'd expect – just, in fairness, what you'd expect from any band who want to convey an Egyptian feeling in their music, from Rainbow to Maiden – while the song itself rocks along, though with perhaps a little too much of a nod to “Powerslave”. Meh, it's okay I suppose.
8. Tell me what to do: Some nice peppy keyboard driving this, and it settles down into a nice funky groove quickly. Another great hook in the chorus. I like this. I like this a lot. The false ending is great.
9. Angel of darkness: Going back to the harder and heavier style for this one, really kicking it. This is why Ten sometimes get called a melodic metal band, though I would never claim they were any such thing. It's the heaviest track so far though, that can't be denied. Good strong ending, when it seemed it was going to fade out.
10. The last pretender: Keeping things powerful and heavy, with definite elements of “Ten fathoms deep” from The Robe. I've actually heard this one before, on a playlist. It's decent enough, if a little derivative.
11. Assault and battery: On the European version the closer is “We can be as one”, which also featured on the Dragon and Saint George EP, but here I seem to have the Japanese version, which gives us this track instead. So we sacrifice the second ballad for a fast rocker (as if you couldn't tell from the title!) which, while it's good, I feel slightly unbalances the album. What's the Japanese's problem with love songs, huh? Not the closer I would have preferred.

Final result: Time was when you could hear a new Ten album and it would be just that: new. It does seem now though that Gary and the boys are looking too much to the past, basically cherry-picking a lot of elements from classic albums and hammering them into new tracks that then don't sound new. As has been the case for me for some time, while I don't hate this album I can't say I love it, and I remain a little disappointed at how unadventurous Ten are being, and how they seem to be content, to a large degree, to not quite phone it in, but maybe Facebook it. Whatever that is. I've heard that's a thing. Is that a thing? Anyway, there doesn't seem to be too much creativity left, which is a pity, as these guys used to be one of my favourite bands. They're still up there, but seem to be doing all they can to step down the ladder.

Rating:

The Batlord · 12-29-2016, 04:56 PM

Oh good now we'll get to go blind trying to read the song titles.

Trollheart · 12-29-2016, 05:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Batlord

Oh good now we'll get to go blind trying to read the song titles.

**** off.

12-29-2016, 04:47 PM	#158 (permalink)
Trollheart Born to be mild Join Date: Oct 2008 Location: 404 Not Found Posts: 26,970	Note: It's come to my notice that the colour I use for "Like" (Orange or even DarkOrange) is a little harsh, so I'm changing it now. Here, and in "Love or Hate?", or anywhere else I use my marking system, "Like" will now be indicated by this colour. Title: Isla de Muerta Artiste: Ten Year 2015 Nationality: British Genre: Melodic Rock/AOR Rank: High Priest 12 Expectations: I don't know: I'm a huge fan of this widely unregarded band, yet their recent releases have generally failed to instil in me the fire and passion that their earlier material did. In fact, the last Ten album I could call really great was 2005's The Twilight Chronicles, and while they did impress with 2012's Heresy and Creed, even then I was reaching a little. I've yet to hear the previous year's Albion, though what I've heard from it has given me hope that they may have regained the sparkle that characterised albums such as Return to Evermore, Babylon and Far Beyond the World. Will this, their latest, continue that upward trend? I see the succession of silly covers goes on; these guys don't do themselves any favours with their choice of cover art. The older albums were blander in general, but at least they didn't make you want to roll your eyes. Ah well, on we go. ]1. Buccaneers/Dead men tell no tales: This is the second album, but the first I've heard, to feature a quad-guitar attack, with Gary Hughes and John Halliwell backed up now by two “new” guys (they joined for the previous album, so they're new to me at this point), Steve Grocott and Dann Rosingana. The instrumental beginning is certainly nothing to get excited about, typical Ten instrumental and as it happens mostly driven on keys. They're what usher in the first actual track too; have to say it sounds a lot like “Albion born” off the previous album. Meh, for a band with four guitars to draw on they don't seem to capitalise on this, not so far anyway. A decent song, but it's hardly blowing me away or making me think of classic Ten. All told, fairly weak opener. 2. Revolution: Kind of an almost industrial sound to this, and maybe they're about to use the power of multi-guitars here? Well, if anything this reminds me of Gary Hughes's solo work on the double concept album Once and Future King. Better than the opener though, kicks a little life into proceedings. I can hear the guitars getting into it now. 3. Acquiesce: This has a good sense of fun and almost poppy rock to it, certainly more in the AOR than hard rock vein. Good keyboard runs and some decent guitar; kind of a sense almost of seventies rock too. First decent proper guitar solo here. No idea who's playing it though. 4. The Dragon and Saint George: This track I already reviewed when I looked at the EP of the same name, so if you want to know about it check that review out. 5. Intensify: Now this sounds very familiar: sort of reminds me of “Evil's on top of the world”. Good hook in the chorus though. Probably one of the best so far, which, given that it sounds so much like a previous song, is not really good. Still, I guess I'll take what I can get at this point. Sigh. It never used to be like this. 6. This love: Oh here we go! If there's one thing Gary and Ten do well it's ballads, and here's the first, and it does not disappoint. Almost worth the price of the album by itself. It has everything: great piano line, soft synth, the trademark Ten vocal harmonies and I assume ... yes, there it is, a soaring guitar solo. Formulaic, I guess, but I love Ten ballads, and their albums would not be the same without at least one. Oh, that has cheered me up. Now let's see if we can keep this mood, although... 7. Karnak/The Valley of the Kings: Ten do tend to use a lot of Egyptian motifs in their lyrics, and I have to be honest, it's getting a little tiresome. The instrumental that precedes the track is just what you'd expect – just, in fairness, what you'd expect from any band who want to convey an Egyptian feeling in their music, from Rainbow to Maiden – while the song itself rocks along, though with perhaps a little too much of a nod to “Powerslave”. Meh, it's okay I suppose. 8. Tell me what to do: Some nice peppy keyboard driving this, and it settles down into a nice funky groove quickly. Another great hook in the chorus. I like this. I like this a lot. The false ending is great. 9. Angel of darkness: Going back to the harder and heavier style for this one, really kicking it. This is why Ten sometimes get called a melodic metal band, though I would never claim they were any such thing. It's the heaviest track so far though, that can't be denied. Good strong ending, when it seemed it was going to fade out. 10. The last pretender: Keeping things powerful and heavy, with definite elements of “Ten fathoms deep” from The Robe. I've actually heard this one before, on a playlist. It's decent enough, if a little derivative. 11. Assault and battery: On the European version the closer is “We can be as one”, which also featured on the Dragon and Saint George EP, but here I seem to have the Japanese version, which gives us this track instead. So we sacrifice the second ballad for a fast rocker (as if you couldn't tell from the title!) which, while it's good, I feel slightly unbalances the album. What's the Japanese's problem with love songs, huh? Not the closer I would have preferred. Final result: Time was when you could hear a new Ten album and it would be just that: new. It does seem now though that Gary and the boys are looking too much to the past, basically cherry-picking a lot of elements from classic albums and hammering them into new tracks that then don't sound new. As has been the case for me for some time, while I don't hate this album I can't say I love it, and I remain a little disappointed at how unadventurous Ten are being, and how they seem to be content, to a large degree, to not quite phone it in, but maybe Facebook it. Whatever that is. I've heard that's a thing. Is that a thing? Anyway, there doesn't seem to be too much creativity left, which is a pity, as these guys used to be one of my favourite bands. They're still up there, but seem to be doing all they can to step down the ladder. Rating: __________________ Trollheart: Signature-free since April 2018