Key

Instrumentally they're great. As I said, I think they'd do fine as a strict instrumental band. It'd be interesting to say the least.

Key

#93: Pink Floyd (Syd Barrett)

• I can't stomach Barrett's vocals.
• The Piper At The Gates of Dawn has to be my least favorite Pink Floyd album ever. I've listened to it twice. Least listened album in my collection probably.
• Once I heard The Wall and Animals, it was very difficult to stomach anything Barrett touched.
• I personally feel that Pink Floyd got more success without Barrett involved.

I'll be fair and say that a Sauceful of Secrets was decent at best.

Howard the Duck

pretty much disagree with you about the Pumpkins and Floyd/Barrett

though i don't really like Siamese Dream much, i do adore Mellon Collie & The Infinite Sadness

and as for Piper, yes, it's overrated, but don't just casually dismiss Syd, at least hear his solo albums first

__________________


Malaise is THE dominant human predilection.

Key

Disagreements are bound to happen, especially since this is an opinionated thread, not one built on fact. I've heard some of Barrett's solo work, and I didn't like it too much.

I just can't stomach anything from the Pumpkins when I am very not in love with the style of vocals.

Norg

MIKE PATTON

• man of 1,000 voices...prob one of the best voices in 'MUSIC"
  
  every band he fronts or album he puts out is a different music style or he is his own genre "patton music " and pretty much put the term Alternative or ALt rock on the map
  
  i think he speaks like 3 different languages and he never ages seriously LOL meaing he looks good ...NO HOMO
  
  I like the way he uses every tool toy and music maker to add different sounds to his music
  
  ummm... he dissed Wolfmother LOL

Howard the Duck

uh, this is milano's 100 bands he loves or hates, it's not open to the public

and i would diss wolfmother, what's so funny about that?

__________________


Malaise is THE dominant human predilection.

Key

Um. Make your own thread...?

Norg

or it is i thought it was open to all of US ....:P

so selfish of this OP its all about him right : )

Key

Read the first post in the thread.

I'm not being selfish, it's a personal list of bands I like or hate. If you want to make one, do it. But don't post in mine. Not only is it not your place to say, it's also disrespectful.

I also find it kind of ironic how you say i'm selfish, yet you created both of these:

http://www.musicbanter.com/general-m...ist-songs.html & http://www.musicbanter.com/general-m...50-albums.html

Norg

Awww u caught me red handed yes i made thoes threads .....But i let them die a slow death LOL