Quote:
Originally Posted by Wayfarer
I always find it funny how fans cite her earlier piano-oriented material that you can find on YouTube as an example of how talented she actually is, yet all that really proves it that she's not particularly concerned with authenticity and that she only created this persona to gain fame because the lovelorn, piano-playing singer/songwriter gig wasn't taking her where she thought it might. The most one can give her credit for is devising a pretty nifty marketing scheme.
|
She didn't even really fully create the persona. She enlisted the help of Rob Fusari a producer who she basically was banging at the time. He 'introduced' her to dance music, as well. Essentially, he codevised the character, and entirely co-written, and produced 'The Fame'(even though she flat out denies anyone else wrote anything for it...).
Once she stated getting momentum, she stopped banging Fusari, and started becoming this overhyped psuedoartist whose only legitimacy comes from what appears to be an extremely temporary stint in a high end music school. She became a celebrity, and political icon. Continuing with the character/style of which she only adopted because she knew it'd be commercially viable. Not an iota of honest sentiment or feeling in it's creation.
Besides, all the people who praise her for her piano work are the kind of people who really don't explore piano work, and it's history, much deeper than say Billy Joel, or Elton John(Both of which were brilliant AND original, but not a full catalog on the instrument's history or potential). Her style of playing is basically a dime a dozen talent. Since she is incapable of marrying it with true originality, even that is a gimmick.