I've had this same conversation and debate about genres in literature.
I think that "labelling" music or whatever it is, stunts its growth.
Often, people get far too caught up in genres.
i.e. "I like everything EXCEPT COUNTRY."
i.e. "I only like indie music."
etc.
This causes them to close their minds to a lot of music. They won't listen to a genre of music rather than just listening to the music and judging it on the sound or the effect it has on them.
I think I disagree with Brennan, I really don't think a lot of people agree with this. I think most people, especially here, are focused on the genres and types and popularity of music over their sound. They'll listen to something based on what other people think or want rather than what they really would like or want to listen to.
Also, the original OP was far to long. I didn't read it all, so if I'm going off in the wrong direction, forgive me, but that was an essay.
|