Quote:
Originally Posted by Trollheart
I recently had occasion to move all my music collection from one drive to another, and subdivided it so that it would be easier to find the music I wanted at any given time. So from everything being under "Trollheart's Music Centre" and then listed by band and album, I made subdirectories for rock, pop, classical, instrumental, experimental and so on, with subfolders in each. This left me with something of a dilemma, as it was hard to decide what in my collection that wasn't obviously Rock (Iron Maiden, Thin Lizzy, Rory Gallagher etc) could be seen as such, and what should be classified under the pop banner.
|
A huge problem for me with organizing music by genre is that I don't think genres are exclusive. There's pop-rock or jazz-rock for example. How do you organize those in a genre folder system where you can only apply one genre to an album at a time? By doing it your way, you basically have to work with all those flaws because you can't get around them. That's one of the main reasons why I don't even try that and just keep it alphabetical :
ex.
Code:
Music\Y\Yes\1972 - Close to the Edge [extra info like studio/live album/remaster/label]\01. Close to the Edge.flac
I would only organize music by genres in a media player using file tags and then foobar and perhaps some other players actually tolerate multiple values in a genre tag so that a song can be both Jazz and Rock. Doing it on the folder level seems like a really bad idea (imo).