I think my resentment to
Slumdog Millionaire is aimed less at the movie itself, and the fact that this is the movie that started to get people talking about Danny Boyle. I mean forget
Shallow Grave,
Trainspotting,
28 Days Later,
Millions, and
Sunshine, THIS is the movie that really showcases this man's skill as a director
Call me a cynic, but a part of me thinks this film won out of some kind of pity party from Hollywood to disguise the fact that the Academy Awards are ultimately rich people celebrating the fact that they're rich and famous by giving each other gold statues. I mean there's nothing particularly wrong with the film as a whole, but compared to Danny Boyle's previous works it's really nothing special, it would have like if David Fincher won Best Director for
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo. I'll admit I'm biased towards genre movies because I prefer genre fiction in general, but this has just always been something that's bugged me.
Going back to
City of God, one of the things that I absolutely loved about it was its cinematography which was just absolutely gorgeous. I also think having a native director really helped add a touch of realism to the film in a way that a foreign director just wouldn't have gotten right. It's like if
District 9 had been directed by an American, all that insight into the racial struggles between the white Africans and the black Africans really would have been lost, or at least not as prominently featured. That's another thing that bugged me about
Slumdog Millionaire, I feel it would have been better in the hands of an Indian director, especially when dealing with topics that are really at the heart of that nation, namely the legions of street urchin children. Like, could you imagine a film like
Bend It Like Beckham being directed by say... Guy Ritichie? Yeah I"m sure the football parts would have been great, but all the commentary on the dysfunction of Indian families and this torn feeling of wanting to assimilate while also wanting to cherish your heritage would have been lost.
Wow, I apparently dislike
Slumdog Millionaire more than I like to admit.