Music Banter - View Single Post - Is This Real or Is It Overdubbed?
View Single Post
Old 10-06-2012, 03:25 PM   #4 (permalink)
SATCHMO
Al Dente
 
SATCHMO's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Texas
Posts: 4,847
Default

Some points to consider:

1. You can tell by the camera position, and the fact that it's not steady, that the video more than likely was not professionally done or commissioned by anyone legally associated with the band.

2. No aspect of the recording sounds like it's at the level of studio quality, which is not the same as saying that it's a terrible performance. I've seen C,S,N, (& Y) 3 times and each time their performance has been near perfect.

3. For a live recording to merit studio overdubs it usually has to be for the ultimate purpose of marketing the recording somewhere in the future. No one is going to say, "Hey remember that piece of video we shot a in New York just for ****s and giggles? Why don't we rent studio space time and overdub these tracks to make it sound better just because we have nothing better/more profitable to do." In order to justify the expense there has to be a plan in place for some sort of profitable distribution.

4. The Beatles 1965 concert at Shea Stadium was recorded in... wait for it... 1965. Live recording techniques were not quite as adept as they were when this video was shot (35 years after The Beatles concert). The point being in 1965 there was justification to rework a live recording in the studio and throw down some overdubs, because chances are some of the tracks weren't produced adequately enough. The most famous example of this was The [Charlie Parker] Quintet - Live at Massey Hall (1953), which is one of the most legendary jazz albums in history. Charles Mingus in post-production overdubbed all of his bass tracks for the entire live recording, because his original bass parts were nearly inaudible, as was often the case with upright bass during the early days of live recording. Had that recording been made today, or even 20 years ago, overdubbing the bass parts would have been completely unnecessary.
SATCHMO is offline   Reply With Quote