Quote:
Originally Posted by Mankycaaant
Surely the idea of a concept album is to tell a story over the record with intertwining themes.
|
Usually there needs to be some narrative arc though, not just the illusion of one created by sound unity/cues, vague themes, and cohesion.[/quote]
Quote:
|
I don't know why it matters what's a concept album and what isn't.
|
It only matters when it is an integral part of its value as one of the greatest albums in its field, which I would say is so in this case.
Quote:
|
The only way to know for sure what the true meaning of an album is would be to ask the artist themselves.
|
Where's the fun in that?
Quote:
|
To say "no you're wrong, the album is about Y not X" is stupid because just like musical taste, interpretation is subjective.
|
Yes, to only use that much of an argument and
not supply reasons why it is about y not x is stupid.
Quote:
|
It seems a little pretentious to me that people are trying to slate this album for not following a 'concept'. I wasn't aware to release a good album it needed to follow a 'concept'
|
This has already been covered above.
Quote:
Really, I'm not here to start an argument, but the new member with the cat avatar was giving his opinions on why he thinks MBDTF is conceptual and was basically told "no you're wrong"
Vintage Music Banter logic.
|
Now I want you to keep in mind that when I entered the conversation I was finding this tactic of discussion dominant:
Quote:
Originally Posted by catsandmusic
i'm going to start laughing if you actually claim MBDTF isn't a concept album 
|
and when i retorted:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Surell
Please enlighten us then.
|
I got:
Quote:
Originally Posted by catsandmusic
|
So when you try to catch me on some:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Surell
Ok, it is a concept album if you're the kind of person who got suckered by oxy-clean commercials.
|
And hit me with some:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mankycaaant
Despite interpretation being subjective. Nobody is right or wrong.
|
I'm gonna call you on it because it seems like you walked in a little late and it shows.
Besides, as said before, yes, there is right and wrong. If one can provide reasons as to why the artistic merit of
a is greater than that of
b, and another cannot provide such reason, then one can be right, and another can be wrong.