Music Banter - View Single Post - We've got a major problem...
View Single Post
Old 08-17-2013, 11:24 AM   #353 (permalink)
sopsych
Music Addict
 
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: indoors
Posts: 722
Default

Excellent replies in the past day. (Probably would have gone worse if I'd made more than one post.)

Quote:
He complains that there is no music discussion happening, and when I pointed out some new threads that he could participate in or simply just read and browse through, he shot them down saying he did not wish to participate, and did not investigate into OTHER threads himself, as if the threads I chose were the be all and end all of music discussion here. I'm seriously at a loss for what can or should be done now to say to this member "Look there are all kinds of discussions happening!" and provide some links as a starting point. Not even bothering to check out existing music and other active discussions, and then coming here to complain about the lack of conversations happening, is crazy.
That's an exaggeration. Like I said, the music sub-forums I follow (and one I consider the main part of the site) don't look more active to me, and I view them daily, scanning for things worth replying to.

Now I admit I did sneer at one solution, people making more music threads. It does work a little, if it can be sustained. (But forcing people, such as me, to make music threads doesn't work.)

Edit: another point that I'm following-up on is that publicly telling one person (or maybe two) to calm down usually doesn't work, but (as done on other forums) it can work to politely request that a few people disengage from each other (or, for example, the thread will be locked or moved).

Also, actually I don't necessarily agree that current moderators are mostly responsible for the slide. From what tore has indicated, drama has been driving away people since even before he was a moderator. Furthermore, in the past few years, new member influx was going to decline anyway (because of Facebook, etc.), and when you have the same regulars for years, problems are almost inevitable. But I think some of the decline can be reversed and have been frustrated for over a year at a lack of changes in that regard.

It's unfortunate that between my abrasive nature in this sub-forum (pointed language more so than my points) and my lack of valued music posts (despite intent), my ideas don't get much credit. Because I do have ideas, and I do think some of them could help. I hope that they're among the ideas duga is considering - I've been waiting the length of this thread for someone to say that there might be subtle, direct, non-technical changes for reducing drama. It seems to me that "the needs of the many" includes less drama.
__________________
If you have ideas or feedback for the site, visit The Musicbanter Improvement Thread.

Last edited by sopsych; 08-17-2013 at 11:40 AM.
sopsych is offline