Quote:
Originally Posted by sopsych
"Banter" in this thread - the same way music threads often get derailed.
If people want catchy phrases, then from Duck Tales, "Work smarter, not harder." To echo Pedestrian, I am not personally going to work hard creating threads when they likely would be sabotaged by horseplay and/or personal attacks. If you want to pressure someone to be the change agent, pressure tore or someone else with leadership potential.
|
1 - Again, holding his apparently godlike input hostage unless we meet his demands of fixing the forum for him before he comes along and contributes, because the lack of HIM is what's sucking the life out of this forum.
2 - Personal attacks like the one this entire sequence of posts is against the current mods.
3 - Great idea, force someone to lead a group they don't want to!
Quote:
Originally Posted by sopsych
The usual defensiveness and near-defeatism. I doubt Yac refuses to make any technical changes, and technical changes are secondary for the issues that are bothering members. Many of us want more substance and less fighting. It sometimes feels like members vs. moderators, and no site can thrive that way. Friendly, visionary, can-do - I don't see those characteristics applying to any current mods, and I mean that matter-of-factly, not as an insult (I'm not "friendly" myself). Do any non-friends of the moderators disagree with my assessment? We need some moderators with those traits. If tore is more talk than action, then point me to someone with the right traits who is willing to be a moderator, my proposal to "be a part of the solution." This site can improve, if people are properly empowered.
|
1 - Refuses, again, to accept that the technical changes he's asked for are not reasonable given the forums power structure.
2 - Accuses the mods of starting an "us and them" war - funny, then, that he's attacking them constantly while the MODS started the thread for input into the forum and have expressed, over and over, their willingness to listen to anyone except sopsych, the guy who's attacked them in nearly every post, and has a sig which can only be read as "This place is terrible make it better for me"
Quote:
Originally Posted by sopsych
It would be better and smarter to just agree with me. If enough people did that, the site could undergo positive change. That I'd much prefer over complaining.
|
1 - "Again, I must remind you folks, that the lack of MORE OF *ME* and listening to *ME* is the problem here! All hail *ME*, THE SAVIOUR!"
Quote:
Originally Posted by sopsych
One-liners don't belong in this thread.
Okay, if Yac isn't the main man on technical decisions, who is, the corporate owners? Lessen our "ignorance." But as for new moderators, the idea isn't special negotiating powers on their part - technically, this site isn't bad, in my opinion. New moderators are for willingness to more strongly enforce rules against nastiness. A wide range of people in this thread have requested that policy change, but at least one moderator since seems to have more or less dismissed it and I suspect a few of them are the reason for the long status quo on that.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by sopsych
One-liners don't belong in this thread.
Okay, if Yac isn't the main man on technical decisions, who is, the corporate owners? Lessen our "ignorance." But as for new moderators, the idea isn't special negotiating powers on their part - technically, this site isn't bad, in my opinion. New moderators are for willingness to more strongly enforce rules against nastiness. A wide range of people in this thread have requested that policy change, but at least one moderator since seems to have more or less dismissed it and I suspect a few of them are the reason for the long status quo on that.
|
1 - Finally accepts that his previous suggestions are infeasible, claims ignorance. Again, this was common knowledge for YEARS, and the reason YOU stepped down - Why is he campaigning so strongly for you to return to a moderators position if he doesn't even know why you stepped down?
2 - Wish I knew who these people are that wanted the policies changed to be less lenient on "meanness", since I seem to recall all the mods and members in this thread agreeing that we wanted more free, open, and fun music discussion, not some draconian law bringing down upon anyone who was the slightest bit mean. In fact, we had old and new members alike pointing out that new members are NOT treated significantly differently now, than they were 5 years ago. In fact, we had one member who made two intro threads, 5 years apart, and got the exact same general treatment in both!
Quote:
Originally Posted by sopsych
I wasn't trying to sound like Hal 2001. That movie probably is the worst alleged "masterpiece" I've ever seen. I am right about that too.
Anyway, tore now seems to somewhat agree with my main point. But where are potential moderators? If tore, Pedestrian, etc. don't want to do that, can they please at least name or privately seek out reform-minded candidates? After that would be the hard part about making room for them as moderators.
I fully believe that if the community becomes less harsh, people like me will step up with more music-related contributions.
One last question in this post: has moderating posts ever been tried as a way of "training" people to not fight with each other?
|
1 - "I'm so right about everything, I know better than movie critics, objectively!"
2 - "Tore agrees with me so you should too"
3 - "I'm assuming that if tore becomes a mod again he's ALREADY going to be onboard with tossing out the entire modship and starting from scratch"
4 - "If the community does as I say, I'll contribute, and NOBODY can possibly give up THAT opportunity, right?"
5 - Holy crap that suggestion about moderation being used as training is stupid.
Quote:
Originally Posted by sopsych
Amen. I wish Pedestrian, Trollheart, and others would reiterate their points from a few days ago, instead of letting it seem like it's just whipping-boy me who wants things to change.
Edit: "train" was in quotes to be somewhat facetious, although I do believe that forum atmospheres do partly condition members' behavior and that moderators theoretically could deliberately condition troublesome members' behavior. It's part of my idealistic hope that nobody gets banned and instead everyone can enjoy the forum and not hate anybody. (No, I didn't just get body-snatched.)
Another question: is it possible to moderate entire threads? I've never heard of that on any forum, but it's a nice feature to fantasize about.
|
1 - Funny, aren't Ped, Trollheart, and "Others" now the ones who want sopsych to shut up? Why would they come to his aid?
2 - More requesting features after being told (and apparently accepting) that feature requests are not feasible. Head, meet wall.
Quote:
Originally Posted by sopsych
I have never paid attention to those sections. Yes, that is what I mean. Is it possible to turn moderation on for an existing thread in another section?
As for behavioral change, if I start threads again now, 1) I'll be ticked off at reactions and 2) that lessens incentive for moderators and other members to rein in the nastiness.
|
1 - "If I start threads NOW, *YOU* people will *RUIN* them, and then I won't look fantastic, so why would I do it?"
Quote:
Originally Posted by sopsych
I dislike false accusations of trolling. I didn't come here to be abused. This is supposed to be a site for good music discussion, but because it isn't someone other than me created this thread. Don't blame me for this site's problems.
|
1 - "Waaaaaaaahhhhhh, I'm a VICTIM because people aren't listening to me, and are DARING to get annoyed with my repetitive, endless prattle about how great *I* could make the forum! Its not MY fault I could make this forum so great and none of you are listening to me! Its *YOUR* faults!"
Quote:
Originally Posted by sopsych
Good stuff there, including many points I hadn't thought of. Although if part of that refers to me, I want to clarify that I'm not blaming everything on the mods or even much on most of the mods.
I'd move on myself if I knew of a site that's more active than this with a decent atmosphere and discussion about many different genres of music.
|
1 - Coulda fooled me boss, you've been going after the mods this whole damned time. Well, in between telling us how great you are and how us ushering in your golden age would help us all have an amazing forum.
2 - Please move on anyway, thankyou.
Quote:
Originally Posted by sopsych
I know for a fact I'm considered a troll, and I believe that was a swipe at me and perhaps intended to scare me. But I'm not a troll. If tore had said those things instead of me, it would have gone over fine. Trolling isn't much of a problem on this site, from what I've seen. (Most trolls would want a larger audience.)
How about people actually comment on rostasi's post? I guess I'm ever the optimist that many people will realize the disease before it kills this place.
|
1 - "I'm innocent! A victim! If I were one of the ruling elite, you'd respect me, you bourgeois pigs!"
2 - "I know something you guys don't know, loooooool the disease, the disease!"
Quote:
Originally Posted by sopsych
Well, I don't understand it, unless it's simply a tendency for people to label loudly stated unpopular opinions as trolling. I have been accused of that a few times elsewhere, and I have seen it happen to others, mostly to individuals who start threads. 'Funny' thing is that, in this case, my opinion isn't unpopular - the subject was brought up by Pedestrian or actually by a mod (Duga) who probably thinks I'm a trouble-maker, and several other members have commented negatively about the atmosphere. And I will state here, as I did maybe last year, that mods shouldn't egg things on against anyone, for moderators are supposed to appear impartial. Also, in this case, I don't see the opinion as offensive - unfriendly atmosphere doesn't mean members are unusually animal-like or rotten (though I suppose a few are).
|
1 - "I'm a victiiiiim! I'm a victiiiiim! My opinion is totally valid guys!"
2 - Another backhanded swipe at the mods, another accusation of favoritism and nepotism.
3 - "You guys are OK, but some of you are awful people and should feel bad!"
Quote:
Originally Posted by sopsych
I disagree. Sometimes it is related to the drama. I think new members who start threads (outside the Introductions section) are particularly likely to get mad and leave (I didn't get pissed about MB until I made some threads). Because this is duga's thread and he is a mod, I think he should do a statistical investigation of that, looking at 40 non-spamming members who joined in 2013 and tried to start music discussion. Not that all of those members were worth keeping around, but certainly proactive new members is what the site needs.
|
1 - Because I am the arbiter of all things, Duga should go and do some bizarre and likely pointless survey that will doubtless conclude that "Lots of people join and leave forums for no discernible reason, they probably just forgot to check back"
Quote:
That's "winding people up" right there. A common reaction many people on this site get to thoughtful posts, and then some wonder why fights erupt and serious music discussion isn't attempted much Moderators need to make/enforce rules against posts like that and issue warnings (or worse) for them.
Meanwhile, for all the talk about senior members now making more threads about music, I don't see any overall increase in activity in the General Music section.
|
The hilarious thing about this is that Neapolitan's post said nothing more in line with sop's views than "We got some new members in the shoutbox, and they left because they wanted to leave, it was nothing to do with drama", then mentioned that at one point I wanted to leave, but neapolitan asked me to stay. (which was kind of a nonsequitur even in nea's original post).
The post he's responding to literally has nothing whatsoever to do with what he's talking about here. In addition, people pointed out many times after he said this, that to not see the increase in activity, he must have been blind.
Quote:
Ban me for disagreeing with the clique? Brilliant.
I've said many, many times that I'm not going to put time and effort into making threads that are likely to get me attacked and reduce incentive from moderators to change the site's atmosphere. No matter how many threads senior members make, new or sensitive people (mostly women, I suppose) are unlikely to participate enough given the level of meanness on MB. Nobody can force me to start threads, just like you can't purely wish activity from people outside the clique.
I regularly view just a few sub-forums here. The Pop section doesn't seem more active. Not sure about Rock, which is more important. General Music possibly is the most important part of the site, the part making the biggest impression on members who aren't already dedicated to Music Banter - and as I said, it's not improving.
|
1 - "I'm not going to grace you with my presence unless I'm assured a receptive and fantastically supportive audience that will appreciate the greatness of my contributions!"
2 - Yay, sexism! Women are overly sensitive! You ride that misogyny train bro!
3 - "People are mean! People are mean! (Again, despite the fact people had pointed out by this time, a TON of times, that new members are not being dealt with any more harshly than they ever have been - it is the older, ESTABLISHED members who are finding the forum dynamic to be poorer than before, due to the actions of OTHER established members. "
4 - "You guys are cliquey! All of you! I won't start any threads until you fix this! You guys want me to start threads so badly don't you? WELL NOT UNTIL YOU GIVE ME WHAT I WANT BUSTER!"
5 - "The forum that's improving isn't improving! You guys are lying to me!"
Quote:
|
People don't seem to want to think. I already indicated that, besides reducing incentive for policy change, my threads are likely to receive too much negative attention under the current atmosphere. How would that help? More fighting will not revive the forum. Journals, whatever, few people read them and they're unlikely to cause controversy even among quick-tempered members. The sensible plan would be to improve the atmosphere first and then increase traffic with interesting threads by people like me.
|
1 - Anyone who doesn't agree with me is an idiot and can't think!
2 - "I can't POSSIBLY make my fantastic new threads anywhere where people might DISLIKE them! How dare you suggest that!"
3 - "Nobody reads our journals with hundreds of thousands of views and posts! Nobody!"
4 - "The sensible plan would be to improve the atmosphere first and then increase traffic with interesting threads by people like me. " - Does this comment really need any more critique? I mean really, what the actual ****? This guy's ego is off the CHARTS.
Quote:
People shooting the messenger and ignoring tons of evidence instead of admitting the problem.
I hardly see any positive side. Why are my posts concentrated in complaint threads and a few stupid-seeming music discussion threads that haters cite against me? Because most topics aren't good (or are too obscure, a minor distinction), and when I do reply somewhere, it's like posting into thin air. People on this site seem more interested in replying to their friends or attacking anything they disagree with than making enjoyable music discussion. It's a point others have stated in this thread. Even many people who create threads seem to selectively reply within their threads.
|
1 - "Guys, I'm TOTALLY right, you're just stupid for not believing me."
2 - "I am so desperate for attention and positive feedback on EVERYTHING I do, that I will ONLY contribute to the forum if I am guaranteed to recieve ONLY the praise I so truly deserve!"
Quote:
If this thread isn't moved back fast to where it was, Yac will be getting a message about moderator behavior. I have little patience for this garbage. The complaints I've made are shared by others in the original thread - if you want people to blow smoke up your [bleep] on a forum with a feedback section, you should not be a moderator.
|
1 - Holy overreaction batman - did you ever think that maybe you were causing a scene? Get the **** over your gigantic ego.