Quote:
Originally Posted by Taxman
Oh really, that's true. The Smile I'm judging is a kind of mix of them. But you can't really treat Brian Wilson version as "The definite version of Smile" cos it would be unfair. After all has been said and done, it is one of the greatest disasters in the music history that Smile was not released as it was planned in the sixties.
|
I agree you can't treat the Brian Wilson version as definitive, but you can definitely treat it as a legit album that can be judged in album terms.