Quote:
Originally Posted by BastardofYoung
I really have to ask though what scale of rating you use here.
I mean, 8.9 is near perfect. If a movie like American Mary is an 8.9, a film like Shawshank Redemption would be a 42.0. Even in the context of horror I would say if American Mary was 8.9, Halloween or ANOES would be about a 64.3
Not to say I do not accept that this is your opinion, I certainly do.
I just think that movie was pretty middle of the road. It was not awful, but I do not think it is in the ranks of near perfect.
I liked the idea of the film. It certainly tried to go for something that could have been interesting. But the writing is really what stopped it in my opinion. Was rather predictable too.
|
COUGH*
ROXY's personal rating scale.
That isn't up for debate. It's my opinion. Go piss up a rope.