It might be a bad cable, either in the input or output. Try using a different cable for the output. If that doesn't make a difference, try using another microphone cable. A cable tester is well worth the relatively small price...
Amazon.com: Behringer CT100 Cable Tester: Musical Instruments
Usually when I have a problem like that and I'm sure everything's hooked up properly, it almost always turns out to be a bad cable.