Music Banter - View Single Post - Does altruism exist?
View Single Post
Old 08-16-2014, 10:08 PM   #36 (permalink)
John Wilkes Booth
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by The Batlord View Post
How is doing something for your genes doing something for yourself? If sacrificing for your species doesn't make sense then sacrificing for your genes shouldn't either. Neither will help an individual person live on and sacrificing for either has a negative effect on you. What you're talking about sounds more like evolutionary psychology than evolutionary biology, and as far as I know evolutionary psychology borders on pseudo-science at this point.

I know you know vastly more on the subject than I do, so I'm not calling you out, just asking for clarification.
you have to think about how natural selection works. genes are selected in a population based on success. if you are willing to sacrifice yourself for someone who shares a certain gene with you, then that gene can benefit more than if you always act selfishly in that case. think of a parent willing to sacrifice for their children. they can have multiple children that can potentially benefit from this instinct and those children can have a greater change to pass on that gene in even greater numbers. the same doesn't hold true for an instinct to sacrifice for the good of 'the species'. any one particular 'gene' might not benefit from this instinct and so there's no selective pressure for such a gene to develop.

i do disagree with tore that a person is simply their genes and that any given gene's interest is that person's interest. this denies a human being their agency. to counter this point i will offer a simple example. say i have no children and i decide to sterilize myself because i feel having kids would impede on my career/happiness/whatever. am i acting in my own self interest in this case? by the logic that my interests should always necessarily correlate with that of my genes you would have to say no. and yet clearly i have other priorities which are important to me that i am seeking out and so i would say that it only really makes sense from an individual perspective to say yes.
  Reply With Quote