Originally Posted by The Batlord

Really? You're going with that? You're also arguing against vegetarianism then, since we have canines. Hell, you're arguing against homosexuality, since we're not "meant" to procreate with our own gender. You're confusing biology with morality.

I seriously have yet to hear an argument against my and JWB's positions that doesn't amount to either, "It's icky, so therefore it's wrong," or inconsistent claims about consent. Rationalizing cultural taboos is not a legitimate logical argument, and if you're worried about consent then the entire concept of a pet is abusive. Not to mention commercial uses for animal products.