Music Banter - View Single Post - What's The Difference Between Disco and Funk?
View Single Post
Old 12-31-2014, 04:49 AM   #6 (permalink)
Free Mustache
Groupie
 
Join Date: Dec 2014
Posts: 1
Default

Sorry to revive this thread after so many years, but I felt I had an opinion to offer. As a person who's been listening to disco since he was 6 and funk since 11, I'd like to think I'm well versed in this. Over the years I've come to a certain controversial conclusion. Disco is funk. See, the term "disco" didn't come about until the mid '70s, and even then it wasn't widely used. Previously, groups like Chic and The Tavares were referred to as Funk. The songs were fast, and somewhat simple, but they were just a different kind of funk. However, funk "purists" (though I'd prefer to call them snobs) concluded that this type of music could not be funk (just as death metal fans decided that hardcore isn't metal). What clinches this conclusion, in my opinion, is a song from the 80's that not many consider; Notorious by Duran Duran featuring Nile Rogers (Chic). Is this song Disco, funk, Jazz, Rock, or Pop? It had all of the obvious hallmarks of funk (focus on rhythm rather than lead, experimental sound, synth or keyboard, brass, and a distinct vocal lead over a rhythmic backing) but no one wants to call it funk. This to me shows that there's a certain snobbery that comes with classifying certain kinds of music as funk or disco. It seems to be that whatever fast funky song one person likes is funk, while to another it is dirty disco. It's all funk to me. Some is fast and poppy, and others are Deep or P.
Free Mustache is offline   Reply With Quote