Quote:
Originally Posted by Puffnstuff
I like how anybody who voices an opinion contrary to some people in here gets attacked for it. This is why many people do not participate in these threads and you always see the same posters rehashing the same old rhetoric time and time again. I tend to think of it as musical incest and we all know what happens when the tree has no forks in the branches. I love dynamical music which is why I love symphonic and gothic metal so much. The artists can play straight metal or incorporate elements of many different genres into their songs. Many can even play straight classical and sound better than a dedicated classical artist because their influences are so vast.
|
And yet you don't understand why screamed vocals/growled vocals play their role in Metal. There was nothing incorrect about The Batlord saying that you calling vocalists that scream through entire songs or albums lack talent was ignorant. That is because your opinion came from lacking understanding as to why there's the screaming. One reason is that it's one big part of metalcore, as well as other variant genre's of the Metal tree. There's been plenty of bands that incorporate the screaming/clean vocals in Metal, and almost every variant genre of it; there's that dynamic you like.
It's one thing to discuss something and understand it. But it is another to discuss something and not understand it at all.
Sorry. But you do sound ignorant on the matter.
Quote:
Originally Posted by YorkeDaddy
No one's being attacked you oversensitive weirdo. When someone classifies an entire subgenre as "lacking talent" then it's perfectly reasonable to expect fans of that genre to jump in and give a counterpoint
|
It's not just because he classified an entire subgenre as lacking talent. He is convinced he knows what he's talking about, and that's with him so far showing no evidence that he knows what he's talking about, and he is showing no evidence for why he's right or to back what he's said...even though he's completely wrong.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Puffnstuff
I rest my case.
|
What case? You brought it all on yourself. People react in the way appropriate to how you've handled yourself so far in this thread. If you want that to stop. Well, does it have to be spelled out for you?