Quote:
Originally Posted by tore
Okay. I think there's a way to hand out custom infractions. I have one myself from Yac.
Either way, it's just a suggestion. If it's not practical in its current state, perhaps a change in some of the details would help.
|
Yes, you can do custom infractions. But having to do custom infractions which contradict the existing system every single time feels like it goes against the very premise of your proposal.
Quote:
Originally Posted by tore
Possibly the short posts rule should be eliminated. It's not enforced today and so means little. You may be getting hung up on details and not seeing the bigger picture.
And yes, it does eliminate context in the most common situations. That's how it should be. You shouldn't have to treat every enforcement of a rule like it was uncharted territory and an excercise in judgment. Unusual situations should call for that and they're not going away.
Animosity would occur, but less so when people wrap their heads around this. Let's say I decide to insult someone. I know what the rules are, I know what the consequences should be, but I do it anyways. If you then infract me, I'm gonna think "fair cop". I know what I did, probably thought it was worth it and your response was predictable and already described to me in the rules.
Animosity today is generated because punishment is unpredictable and personal. My suggestion makes punishment predictable and unpersonal. Plus, getting an infraction is not the end of the world and people would still get away with things. It just puts a cap on how much of a rule breaker you can be before you disappear for a while.
|
My comments about enforcement of the short posts rule were meant as an example of the issues I see with your proposal. I actually think there are good reasons to keep that rule, but that's a side issue, my main point is simply that, like a lot of rules, it's very context dependent. The issue of context is not a minor thing, it's a fundamental point about the nature of rule enforcement which you and I disagree on. I think taking a one size fits all approach which disregards context actually
leads to unfair rule enforcement and generates more animosity because people get upset about the thoughtlessness of the way the rule is being enforced. As others have pointed out, it also doesn't really make sense on a board this size because the mods, for better or worse, are also active members of the site, not dispassionate third parties as they might be on, say, the comments section of a major news outlet's website.
I think, by and large, people get upset when their hand gets slapped. So setting up a situation where mods are slapping hands more often is going to generate more animosity, not less. Plus, it's
still going to require the kind of human judgement that you want to eliminate because mods will still have to decide what constitutes an insult, what constitutes trolling, etc. That situation seems like it will be more hassle, the end result of which will only be more headaches for everyone involved. Doesn't seem worth it at all.
On a side note, sorry it took me so long to respond, this week was my last week at my job so I was trying to squeeze a thoughtful response to your comments in between wrapping up projects, attending farewell events, and preparing for my new job.