Music Banter - View Single Post - Changes to Rule Enforcement
View Single Post
Old 05-30-2015, 06:27 PM   #139 (permalink)
Trollheart
Born to be mild
 
Trollheart's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: 404 Not Found
Posts: 26,996
Default

Disclaimer: Please take into account I have only seen this thread now, it's already 14 odd pages long and I have not the time to read it all yet but wanted to give my thoughts. If these points have been addressed or raised or dealt with before, my apologies but I wanted to get this down while it's fresh in my mind. So...

This seems too draconian. I think rigidly enforcing some of the below would lead to a much less fun atmosphere and even a climate of fear, where people are afraid to say or do something in case it offends or is taken the wrong way. Batty would have to leave, and I might have to too, as often I break some of these. The ones I have a problem with I've highlighted and explained.

Quote:
Originally Posted by tore View Post


(Whenever a member has 10+ infractions, that member is tempbanned until the total amount again comes under 10. A permanent 10-point infraction is essentially a permaban.)
I don't understand this. How do infraction points decrease? How does "the total amount again come under 10"?
Quote:



• Please refrain from posting meaningless threads, one word (or short) nonsense posts, or the like.
• Please wait a reasonable amount of time before bumping threads. At least 24 hours.
• Please make an effort to ensure your posts are written in an intelligible way and are not formatted in a distracting manner.


5-point infractions

• While debating and discussion is fine, we will not tolerate rudeness, insulting posts, personal attacks, trolling, purposeless inflammatory posts or members deliberately provoking another member into committing any of these acts.
• Posting or linking to any disturbing, obscene, gory or pornographic material is strictly prohibited.
• MusicBanter does not tolerate plagiarism of material including but not limited to album reviews, blog entries and wikipedia articles. If you wish to use this material on MB, it must be referenced.


10-point infractions

• The solicitation of--or participation in--illegal activities of any kind are not allowed.
• Multiple or repeated posting in order to increase your post count is not allowed.
• Impersonating staff or other users through chat or otherwise is unacceptable for any reason and will result in immediate consequence.




3. Users should be encouraged to reporting posts

It's hard for moderators to police the entire forum. Members can help and should be encouraged to do so.


Highlighted in red: so, no "lol" or smileys or up yours or anything like that???

Highlighted in green: so my "album covers that would piss God off" in Metal Month II last year would be seen as breaking this rule? What about gorey metal or other album covers used in reviews? Or GIFs? Or even avatars?

Highlighted in purple: surely would result in a flood of reports, mostly nonsense, and many made to get back at someone for something?

I must admit, as a non-mod and even non-really-participating member at the moment tore, you seem determined to drag us back into the Dark Ages. What's wrong with what we have now? You may not like it but I think we generally have fun, and if anyone has a real problem they can sort it out. I'm unaware of anyone having a real issue, other than one member, who asked Urban to Warn me, he did, I took it, end of story.

If it ain't broke...

Also, rules that are too harsh are likely to turn away new members I would think.
__________________
Trollheart: Signature-free since April 2018
Trollheart is offline   Reply With Quote