Quote:
Originally Posted by Frownland
It was Script for a Jester's Tear. I don't look down on you for your taste, I'm sorry if you take it that way. Sometimes you do surprise me with some of your verdicts based off of what you've liked before in this thread. I do kind of disagree with your verdict on Masada Guitars because the only thing it seems you didn't really like about it was the length. Based off of that review you would adore the album, but only in small doses.
From what I've heard of Marillion, I don't like them because their music is bloated and full of itself. Their songwriting doesn't impress me and it puts me to sleep. I guess their singer isn't bad, but he's still keeping up with the rest of the band by avoiding doing anything interesting. Lastly:
My first exposure to them was through you when you had put them up against It Bites in some album battles thread. I thought that both were atrocious tbh and that's what's kept me going all this time. I'm a little lighter on them these days now that I know some of their music is just painstakingly boring as opposed to awful, but I'm still no Marillion fan man, nor will I ever be.
|
OK, well thanks for that. At least I now have a better idea of where you're coming from. You do of course know that that singer from Script is gone now and they have a new one? I wouldn't dream of trying to make you like something you don't, but I'll just leave this here in case you decide you want to give the "new" Marillion another chance.
As for Masada, no it wasn't the length (though that did figure in it): as I already explained, I'm not big on guitar-only albums and if they're going to be that then they need to have much more variety and a bit of interest, neither of which I got from what I heard. It was like Cage's string thing. I was just bored. But it's not just you; Steve Hackett, whom I really admire, got the same treatment when it was an album of classical guitar music. I just find it boring, there's no other way to say that. Twenty-one tracks was a lot, though. You might (might) fare better with me if you had shorter albums. Cage's was over an hour, and as for your own.... I'm not overly fond of very long albums, unless they contain music I already like.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Qwertyy
What's my prize for being #100???
|
Cash. Where will I send it?