Quote:
Originally Posted by Machine
Even if that was true (which it isn't as there is completely a point for the composition, but I digress)
|
Besides an intellectual statement? What? Cause no matter what you put on the page, the result would be exactly the same.
Quote:
how would that discredit it as music.
|
By itself, it might not, as written composition isn't necessary to make music (f.ex. free improvisation), but when your composition is an actual lack of sound, then how have you created music?
Quote:
You just agreed with me that silence is part of musical composition.
|
Contraction of the sphincter is also a part of farting. If I contract my sphincter without passing any gas, am I farting?