As I think you know, I also love extremely dissonant music. I'm also not saying that even the very best Genesis is beyond criticism. I get where you're coming from. Especially if you look at their stage theatrics compared to the actual sounds that were coming out. From how they were promoting themselves one would expect something like the oddities of early Pink Floyd, to choose an easy example, but in fact they were much more gentle. So you wouldn't be totally off if you considered them poseurs but it still remains true that, to me at least, their music carries a special ambiance that I find unique and pleasing. To me, the good FAR outweighs the bad. I'm a big fan.
|