The problem with identifying early Genesis as avant garde is that they never explored dissonance, atonality, or any kind of sonic brutality (at least not to any substantial depth). So in that regard, Chula, you're overreaching. However, Frownland, I think you're depriving yourself of some great music by insisting on these qualities as some kind of litmus test. I know you can point out sucky things about Genesis and if you only look at them through those goggles that's all you're going to see. However, I think you're doing yourself a disservice because if you focus on what they do offer instead of what they don't you'll find they really are a great band. Obviously, you can take that or leave it or maybe even save it for later but that's coming from someone who has loved experimental and atonal music since my early teens.
|