Originally Posted by The Batlord

All that gave me was a Google search that included absolutely nothing about Acid Bath. I guess old people just don't know how to use search engines.

Originally Posted by BastardofYoung

nobel of you to vote for the weaker here. But it does not matter now. The better album is going to win. Have you even heard the Acid Bath album? One of, if not the best Sludge album released.

Originally Posted by sicksizza

Acid Bath is amazing.

Originally Posted by Howard the Duck

^^i can empathise with Mondo Bungle there

both equally good albums, but i think Acid Bath has the slight edge, tunes-wise and sheer driving power, the only thing i dislike about it is the over-distorted vocals on some tracks and the truly generic "god machine"

Acid Bath - 4
Neurosis - 1

Originally Posted by LOLPOCALYPSE

I guess I've always found Neurosis to be overrated, but I think Acid Bath wins here by a long shot. Love the vocals, love the riffs, love the variety. The John Wayne Gacy album cover is kind of funny as well

Acid Bath - 5
Neurosis - 1

Originally Posted by BastardofYoung

But yeah, seems like Acid Bath is a love or hate band. People who love em really love em, and people who hate em really hate em. No room for in between it seems.

But there is something in the Acid Bath album that grips me more, especially the songwriting. I think as a lyricist Dax Riggs is top notch. The vocals on the album are top notch, the vocal effects on a song like "The Bones of Baby Dolls" is amazing.

I feel like a traitor going against Melvins, but that Acid Bath album just blows me away every time I listen to it.

Weird with the album, I prefer the slower moments more then the heavier moments. This song blows me away every time I hear it. Never tire of it:

Originally Posted by Unknown Soldier

You guys are mad, Bullhead doesn't even approach the quality of the Acid Bath album. Bullhead is not a bad album, but its nothing special either and I only really like one song off the album "If I had an Exorcism" "Boris" always sounds promising but does drag at 8+ mins. I don't think Bullhead matches Houdini the following album in terms of quality at all.

Acid Bath -4
Melvins -4