I tend to agree with these sentiments. They had two eras, while I would argue that "Orchid" does not feel the same as "Blackwater Park" as they evolved to a peak with "Watershed". The first signs of the current direction of some of the more exclusive 70s prog instruments, like the mellotron, were found in "Ghost Reveries". We shouldn't have been surprised they took this to its musical conclusion: going full metal 70s prog.
It is indeed frustrating to listen to the second era Opeth, although there are some gems on their last album. I can't say the same for Heritage. Sadly it was kind of a foregone conclusion that the growls would be slowly phased out. However, what was so depressing was how it was so sudden a change to no growls at all. While not dissimilar to how My Dying Bride did this with "Angel and the Dark River", Opeth needs to see what they did and transition at least some back to the surprise growl or two in the future. They vocally need to break up the monotony, hopefully they will with the new album in a month. We can hope can't we that they get their fire back....
Quote:
Originally Posted by Qwertyy
I feel Opeth lost their edge when his voice went and while I wouldn't say they're bad now by any means, I definitely don't find their new material as enjoyable as their earlier stuff.
|