Quote:
Originally Posted by Chula Vista
Take 10 members here and ask them to list 10 undisputed classics and I'll wager you'd get quite a bit of disagreement.
|
So...then why use it as a way to back up your claim about Frownland only listening to experimental music? The argument doesn't make any sense, unless I'm missing something.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trollheart
Nothing, as you point out, in music, is indisputable in that regard. The only things actually indisputable are solid facts, such as who played what (not that they did or didn't play well, that's subjective as you say) and who made what album etc. It's kind of like an unspoken thing: ask a hundred people if they think, for instance, "Bohemian rhapsody" is a classic and you'll probably find at least ninety people do. Ask the same people about "Paranoid" and the number will be lower. Nothing can be undisputed in that regard. The best thing you can say, if you want to be literal and accurate, is that insofar as anything can be undisputed in music, this is. Or something.
|
That's a fair point.