Music Banter - View Single Post - The Album Club: "September Winds" by Evan Parker, Hans Anliker, Reto Senn, Peter A Sc
View Single Post
Old 01-26-2018, 08:16 PM   #13 (permalink)
Neapolitan
carpe musicam
 
Neapolitan's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Les Barricades Mystérieuses
Posts: 7,710
Default

Tuesday, Thought about listening to the album, September Winds, all day at work. OK done work, finally home, time to listen to this September Winds. However, instead of going directly to the album I thought I would logged on Music Banter and check to see if there was any reply to the post I made in http://www.musicbanter.com/indie-alt...die-songs.html I remember when I made the list I couldn't exactly think of my top ten indie/alt Rock songs. So I winged it. So I thought I would mention songs perhaps Lisnaholic would like. I thought definitely Outdoor Minor, Testimony and Cathedrals would be nice picks. I imagine him liking those songs. As I was making the list I fell into a slump. I couldn't think of any more songs to add. So I thought if I had one song from 78 I'll add another song from that year Another Girl, Another Planet. I know technically it's not indie/alt Rock, but it's pretty good, it's in the same range I guess. So picking Another Girl, Another Planet made me think of a whole bunch of other songs about space and junk. I started throwing in song like Field of Mars, First Day on a New Planter, Outer Space and Stars - songs like that. Then like any other list I make I am never satisfied. It was half favorite indie love songs half favorite space songs. Maybe I should make a list ahead of time in case such an occasion arises where I have to rattle them off. At least I know what they are and I can also consistently give the same top ten indie/alt Rock songs. So I made that list on Monday and as I was saying on Tuesday I went to check for a reply. I saw Chiomara's post. She mentioned Stars was one of her favorites too! Cool beans, we like the same song. The band top of the list was Dirty Beaches. I want to make a quip about how many bands use "Beach" in they name like "Beach" House and oh this other band with "Beach" in their name which totally escaped me. So I thought well before I make that comment let me first figure out what "Beach _____" band is. I was thinking "Beach Slag" or whatever but here it turns out to be really "Beach Slang." Why do I keep forgetting that name? IDK. So that took some valuable time away from listening to September Winds trying to figure out that band's name. Then it occurred to me 'What do the Dirty Beaches even sound like?' 'Never heard of them.' I thought to myself. So off YouTube I went to find a video, but I never got around to hearing a song by Dirty Beaches or even making that pun about so many bands with "Beach" in there name, cause as I was About to click on the Dirty Beaches video on the sidebar I saw something intriguing caught. I thought was an interesting thumbnail and name and I had to investigate further. It was a band called Kælan Mikla. So I spent most of the night going through Kælan Mikla videos, and then after that I went to plug.dj. So my plan to listen to September Winds on Tuesday night never came to fruition.

Wednesday I finally got down to business to listening to this album September Winds. However I thought I gotta do something else. I thought I know I go to plug.dj, mute it and maybe chit chat with whoever is there. While I was listening to "Insect Part 1" someone on the plug-chat said Mark E Smith has died. I had like a half minute of that song left I thought I wait it out and stop listening to the album, cause I was a bit bummed out. Maybe I shouldn't say "bummed out" that will leave the door wide open for Trollheart to make some kind of joke about bum holes. Let's just say I was a bit sadden by the news. Thelonious Monkey and I talked a little about The Fall, and I mentioned they were from Manchester. I played Rebellious Jukebox for him. He said it was his first Fall song. I was glad to introduce him to the band. I couldn't go back to September Winds that night.

Thurday I came home wiped out, totally knackered. Je suis complètement crevé!. as the French would say. I slept till midnight. I got up. I didn't feel much like eating or anything. So I grabbed myself San Pellegrino then logged on to plug.dj. I saw WWWP and Chio there. Frownland was there but he left exactly before I went to ask him a question - I forget what it was. So anyway while I was in plug.dj I was checking out the latest posts. I told WWWP and Chio that Frownland possibly wrote the longest joke ever told on Music Banter, in Music Banter history. http://www.musicbanter.com/games-lis...ml#post1920079 TBH I gave up reading half way through the first post. I was wondering the whole time could he have somehow leave out most of this, come up with some abridged version but with the same punch line?
I thought I should make a comment too. So I quipped "That's a joke only Leon Trotsky could tell." Then a few minutes later it dawned on me, wait a minute that doesn't make sense at all. I think I just got Leo Tolstoy mixed up with Leon Trotsky. I better change it quick before someone see that. Certainly someone will call me out on that. I don't think I could live down getting caught telling a joke that doesn't not make any sense. All in all, in retrospect, I thought I should have said "This is only a joke Fyodor Dostoyevsky could have told." I thought that that could have gotten a better response, perhaps a LOL from somebody who knows how long Dostoyevsky stories are. Another missed opportunity for funny response and another missed opportunity for a September Wind review.

Friday Today I finally got chance to complete the listening to the album September Winds. I forget what song but there was some disgusting slurping sounds which I thought were quite unnecessary. However for the most part the performance did have merit. I like how the notes change subtly through technique of the player. I liked how they notes resonated. I thought having a five to ten thousand dollar orchestra woodwind sound like a didgeridoo to be quite the accomplishment. The recording also utilizes reverb, whether it was achieve by acoustics of the room the musicians preformed in or it was added later through an effects processor during post-production I do not know. Another thing worth mentioning is at times the notes would pan stereophonically from one channel to another adding a little bit of excitement into the mix. So the combination between the reverberation, the resonance and the panning from one channel to the other all together complimented each other gave the recording a unique spatial quality. In short the album was more about listening for the variation in timbre than about listening to a melody. To sum it all up I thought the best way to critique September Winds is to have a long, drawn out, meandering review to sum up a long, drawn out, meandering album.


rating 4/5.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by mord View Post
Actually, I like you a lot, Nea. That's why I treat you like ****. It's the MB way.

"it counts in our hearts" ?ºº?
“I have nothing to offer anybody, except my own confusion.” Jack Kerouac.
“If one listens to the wrong kind of music, he will become the wrong kind of person.” Aristotle.
"If you tried to give Rock and Roll another name, you might call it 'Chuck Berry'." John Lennon
"I look for ambiguity when I'm writing because life is ambiguous." Keith Richards
Neapolitan is offline   Reply With Quote