Music Banter - View Single Post - What Didn't Burn Away
View Single Post
Old 04-03-2006, 05:45 PM   #3 (permalink)
Crowe
Music Addict
 
Crowe's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2005
Posts: 699
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by DontRunMeOver
Interesting. This is one of those lyrics which I'd really have to hear with music to believe that it will work. It looks fantastic on paper and, as a written poem, reads beautifully with good imagery etc. (apart from the first two lines, which didn't seem to serve any purpose).

When read aloud, the lyric suddenly becomes much weaker. There aren't many lines that sound particularly good. The rhyming parts...


...definitely sounded best, although 'repose' grates a bit (its the 'ru' sound at the beginning of the word) and 'distill' is also a bit ugly.

The rest, while it is excellent in its descriptive wording and ability to set a scene, sounds pretty bad when read aloud. There are many other problems I have with it as a lyric; bad structuring (where are verses, bridges and choruses?); no hooklines; no obvious rhythm (this isn't necessarily a problem in practise, of course).

To summarise, as a poem I love it, as a lyric I really don't like it. You don't need to work on your descriptive abilities at all, but really need to develop an ear for a well-sounded phrase.
This was really well said, and I think that is the problem that plagues most writers on this forum, including me. We know what looks good written down - but then when you try to sing it, something just happens and you're like, where did I go wrong? I've tried putting some of my more well recieved songs to music and sometimes it just doesn't pan out. I'm no shlub either - I can write music... but it either turns out to be a really long song that drags or some sort of progrock anthem with my wordy songs... I dunno. Good call DontRun.
__________________
Crowe is offline   Reply With Quote