One man vs an entire band of men. Ok, lessee here...
Jimi was good on guitar, and I've never heard him on any other instrument, but his songwriting was depressing af. He 'borrowed' a lot from other artists too. The Beatles were extremely proficient songwriters and blazed a musical trail of their own.
So given that knowledge, on a scale from 1-5, with 5 being great and 1 being crap, here's my ratings:
Bass
Jimi=0 | Paul=3
Drums
Jimi=0 | Ringo=2
Vocals
Jimi=2 | John/Paul/George/Ringo=4
Guitar
Jimi=4 | George/John/Paul=3
Overall Songwriting
Jimi=3 | Beatles=5
Jimi=9
Beatles=17
__________________
See location...
|