Quote:
Originally Posted by elphenor
again his only point is that if you look at economic growth it was a success
the least developed nations could suddenly compete with the most developed
|
I've already addressed this.
His point was that they grew fast. Specifically, his point was that they grew fast as a response to the charge that socialism hasn't worked when its been tried. In other words he's saying actually these planned economies did work well, based on said growth.
Now if you just take that statement on the surface, which you seem to do, it might sound like a good point. If you start to analyze the context and the history even the slightest amount it completely falls to shreds. He relies on the ignorance of his audience and opponent to make this point stand.
But if you analyze it in detail, you see clearly that the main innovation that sped up the growth was simply mass murder through stealing the crop yields. Yes you can argue this was the most efficient way to industrialize the ussr as rapidly as they did, and you can even argue that its what allowed them to build up their armaments in order to withstand WW2. But to make that argument to have to actually endorse the policy and the resulting genocide, which he and you are both unwilling to do so once again the rapid growth is a moot point.
The reason this frustrates me more than anything else is that if he just stuck to arguing for co ops I would more or less agree with me. When he talks about the tyranny of the workplace that resonates with me. When he starts using this soviet shell game to sell the idea that command economies have been a success story or added some sort of innovation we can learn from, he's selling snake oil. He needs to ditch that angle imo.