To be honest, I prefer a free forum with a simple format, like what we have here. I don't like complicating my life with annual payments or online purchases, so my objection to paying is mainly about the process.
On the other hand, I would hate to be the only guy at the party who turned up without a bottle of booze, so if people accept the idea of paying, I would fall in with the majority.
Sorry to be such a half&half voter, but could you make that position one of the poll options, please?