@ guybrush
So first of all I think that we should clarify: when you say most human behavior is a result of selfishness, do you actually mean that all human behavior is driven by selfishness? Because that's the impression that I get from you. If not, then what are the exceptions?
The reason why I ask is because like I say, if all behavior is derived from selfishness then good behavior is also derived from selfishness. So we haven't said anything that is truly distinct to or explanatory of what we consider evil behavior.
Even in your monkey analogy, you say that the monkeys that are employing the "selfish" strategy make the altruistic system unstable. I understand the point you're making here about the cost benefit analysis of different strategies but doesn't this analogy about the corrupting influence of selfishness presume that the monkeys who are performing the grooming are somehow being less selfish? If we say no because their behavior is guided by kin selection and reciprocity then in what sense is the monkey who is being a free rider being more selfish by your definition?
I think when people generally talk about selfishness we do so in the context of human society and expectations. And the unit you are being selfish towards is the individual rather than just being selfish on behalf of your genes. And yeah I think most evil acts are going to probably be selfish to some degree, some more than others, but I don't know that the selfishness itself is what makes an act evil.
Also disclaimer for the term evil: I don't believe in it in some platonic sense either but I think most of us at least have behavior that falls into that category for us. I think we can use the term subjectively without attaching some sort of metaphysical implication to it.
|