Music Banter - View Single Post - Human Beings.
Thread: Human Beings.
View Single Post
Old 11-02-2006, 07:57 PM   #9 (permalink)
cardboard adolescent
;)
 
cardboard adolescent's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: CA
Posts: 3,511
Default

I don't think either is entirely right. I think humans are born with a biological survival instinct, which, in a society like ours, in which one must compete for his basic needs, manifests itself as a constant struggle, a competition to a) survive and b) secure as many of life's luxuries for oneself. In a society in which basic needs as well as luxuries were guaranteed for everyone, I think the survival instinct wouldn't dominate our course of action, and everyone could hypothetically co-exist peacefully.

So, I don't support Hobbes' view that man is fundamentally self-serving and apathetic to the plight of others, rather I think Rousseau is closer when he says that society has made man to be this way. And really, all you need to do is find a society in which man has no need to compete and observe their peaceful cohabitation. And I'm sure societies like that exist around the world (mostly aboriginal, I'm sure). But, at the same time, in even the most peaceful tribe, it seems that conflict is inevitable. I don't attribute this to some flaw in human nature, but random chance. Maybe by some genetic defect a person is born predispositioned towards violence, maybe some event in their early childhood led them to become embittered towards existence or their peers. I don't really know how it happens, but it seems it always does. Even in a perfect society you would have bad seeds, and it's all a matter of how you make a social construct that allows people the greatest freedom and yet protects the stability of the society from the actions of... delinquents?

So when it comes to actually making a government, a state, whatever, I think Hobbes is full of crap. Though he basically says the same thing I just said, that we need to give up some of our freedom to ensure civil defense, his endorsement of a strong, overbearing authority seems to contradict his own understanding of human nature. A construct in which those who have all the freedom and all the luxuries are given all the power over everyone else, there is no incentive to share their freedom or wealth, and such a system can only lead to corruption and further stripping of power from the masses.

Democracy seems to be the best way to go when it comes to representing the views of the people fairly, yet even democracy has its flaws. As Churchill said, "Democracy is the worst form of government except for all the others." Personally I think the system of government in place in America is relatively fair, as far as governments go, though I would support the removal of the electoral college and the institution of a policy of proportional representation for elections.

Economically speaking, capitalism seems to support all of the evils that have been discussed, the struggle for wealth and unending conflict between people and states. Socialism, however, isn't necessarily much better, though the people's basic needs are guaranteed, all of the luxuries are still concentrated in the hands of the few. Additionally, you've now taken away some of the freedom of the people and added to the authority of the state, giving them additional governing rights over industry and agriculture. And then finally, with the extreme alternative, communism, noone really has the luxuries, and in practice, the kind of suppression and exertion of control required to put a system like communism in place is extremely unstable and inneffective. For communism to ever work, people would have to come to it naturally, given a great deal of time, and either such a plethora of luxuries where competition would be unnecessary, or where the luxuries are so concentrated that almost all of the people are without them anyway so communism does not represent that great of a change.

I'm not even really sure what I started out talking about anymore, I guess it was the nature of man, I don't know if I even really answered the question. But if even one person reads that I guess I'll get a sense of accomplishment.
cardboard adolescent is offline   Reply With Quote