Music Banter - View Single Post - Human Beings.
Thread: Human Beings.
View Single Post
Old 11-03-2006, 08:35 PM   #15 (permalink)
Sneer
Let it drip
 
Sneer's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2004
Posts: 5,397
Default

OK, i see your point, i was attempting to be purposefully vague because i didnt want to go into too much detail with it all. Basically, from my own interpretation and as people have already stated, human beings are born with this innate, natural instinct to survive. They constantly desire and therefore can never be fully satisfied due to to this continuing desire for food, warmth, land etc. If other humans were to impose on these desires, naturally a conflict would occur. the "war" idea was probably due mostly to the fact Hobbes wrote this amidst the height of the English civil war - which was composed of two sets of men with completely conflicting desires - which due to passion escalated into warfare. This revolt against the monarchy showed to Hobbes that without the soviergnty and a divine figure to pass rulership, people would resort to a state of anarchy and violence. As most can see, this theory has many many flaws but i think Hobbes portrayal of the natural human state is quite correct. He believed we were naturally volatile, violent creatures and think about it, when your getting on the bus or train for work/school in the morning and theres a mass of people all scrambling and pushing for a spot on the transportation, dont you feel incredibly aggravated? its our natural state which is quelled by the (to an extent) democratic society we live in. So i think though Hobbes theory of man was closer to the truth, Rousseau's solution was alot more effective. Which is quite odd considering he meant it for naturally compassionate, loving people. In saying that, i dont think human beings are solely violent, aggressive people, their main aim is to survive, to support families and loved ones. So love is a main factor.
Sneer is offline   Reply With Quote