Quote:
Originally Posted by Alexander the Grape
Or we could just completely disregard genres and only judge music as good or bad on a band-to-band basis.
And I have to say that I enjoyed everything by AFI up to Decemberunderground, which I can't stand. Even Sing the Sorrow wasn't too bad. It certainly was more interesting and creative than their earliest hardcore punk records.
|
youre probably like the millionth person who has suggested getting rid of genres completely but yeah it doesnt work like that
decemberunderground wasnt a punk album it wasnt even hardcore bands are allowed to make one bad cd in their career afi chose to do that with decemberunderground because that album wasnt good of course some other bands abusive that priviledge and every album they release isnt good
"emo" is its own genre its not a sub-genre of punk