Nobody is probably going to agree with me...but seriously. Anyone who has listened to The Fall of Troy, or seen them on youtube or anything...knows that they completely dominate all of the categories.
"Talent: Tim, Thom, and Andrew are all amazing. Thomas especially.
Innovation: It doesnt sound like anything else out there right now.
Diversity: You just have to listen for that one.
Showmanship: They put on the most amazing live shows ive ever seen, the pure energy this band gives off.
YouTube - Excreations
So i think everyone needs to seriously consider having them in the top 50. The Mars Volta definetly deserves a spot as well. But my argument right now is for The Fall of Troy.