The Ramones never got popular until very recently, but now they're extremely popular. They frequently appear on greatest bands lists, normally I don't use that because in alot of cases it doesn't mean much, but vh1, rolling stone, Spin put them as number 2 following the beatles and they were inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, though lately that doesn't say much.
They're influence is huge, Metallica, Dead Kennedys, Black Flag, Tom Waits, the Offspring, Rancid, Guns and Roses, L7, Bad Religion, Motorhead, the Queers, Rooney, Red Hot Chili Peppers, Pete Yorn, the Pretenders, Garbage, Bad Brains, and Megadeth. Plus they're one of the most influential punk bands ever, and arguably the most influential pop-punk band. They were a huge influence on Green Day, their kids were named after them.
The only reason he gave for inducting them that I saw was
Quote:
|
I think History will be kind to them and I don't understand why everyone hates them so much. Say what you will they are popular as all hell among fans of several genres and nobody is apathetic about them, the illicit strong feelings in most cases.
|
Really, the only points are, that history may be kind to them, complete guess work, people having strong feelings about them (which doesn't mean much at all, most popular bands people have strong feelings about) and of course, they're popular. Well that is the only actual reason, and lets look at some popular artists shall we? 50 Cent, Jessica Simpson, Pink, Fergie, Fall Out Boy, Simple Plan, Beyonce, do I need to go on? Popularity doesn't mean sh
it.
Quote:
ERA: The last 100 years of Rock and Roll Music
Genres: All major genres with a Rock & Roll connection
Factors for ranking
#1 Popular Opinion - How is the band viewed both by the public as a whole and amongst their peers.
#2 Commercial Success - Albums sold, Awards won etc.
#3 Longevity - How has the band or artist stood the test of time. Are they still relevant and respected or have they become tacky.
#4 Technical Ability - How good are they at writing songs and playing their instruments
#5 Showmanship - How are their lives shows, TV appearances, interviews etc.
#6 Groundbreakings - What was their impact on culture as a whole, the music world and their genre
#7 Personal Opinion - It's my list it will in part reflect that naturally. I have an eclectic musical taste but am of course as prone to bias as anyone.
|
Popular Opinion: Well, I see the Ramones bashed for being too 'simple' but for the most part people like them alot.
Commercial Success: I don't know about awards, but lately they've sold alot of albums. I'll grab their album sales if you want me to.
Longevity: Over 30 years and still respected and loved.
Technical Ability: Not very, but this punk not metal.
Showmanship: I've read one interview with Joey Ramone, it was interesting I don't see why interviews matter I mean what does it have to do with music? Look at Nick Drake, I guess showmanship wise he would've technically sucked but does that make him bad? No. The Ramones were amazing live from what i've heard/seen.
Groundbreakings: I already posted about how influential they were, they weren't a super original punk band there were others doing similar stuff but they certainly were one of the best at it.
Personal Opinion: Well obviously they fail that, which is probably going to be the problem with this list.
With the exception of Personal Opinion, I think the Ramones have Green Day beat in every category.