Quote:
Originally Posted by Brock_West
Wow, now I have my proof that you're a twelve year old pre-pubescent boy.
|
Yep, which explains why I'm the one not backing up my argument and resorting to petty comments and assumptions.
Quote:
|
We have different views on The Beatles. I don't like Rubber Soul, you don't like Help! Neither one understands the other. I've met some funny Admins, but you take the cake by far. So pissy. Haha
|
I never said I didn't like Help!
Quote:
|
I'd also be interested to know if you like Magical Mystery Tour.
|
It's my fourth favorite Beatles album, as I said earlier.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brock_West
Well none of us really know exactly just when Paul, John, George, and Ringo got hit with the thunderbolt and decided to do something different. We do have the music however, which speaks for itself.
|
Agreed, which is why every Beatles fan I know says Rubber Soul is where the changes begin to appear.
Quote:
|
Rubber Soul seems very downbeat with a few exceptions (Drive My Car), that track obviously similar to earlier Beatles tunes.
|
Lyrics like that would never have appeared on Help!
Quote:
|
Nowhere Man and Norwegian Wood are abstract but not very complex or outstanding.
|
Music has to be complex to be innovative?
Quote:
Here, I'm going to quote Wikipedia (to be lame of course) : "The song 'Wait' was initially recorded for, and then left off, the album Help!. The Beatles chose not to include it on Help because they thought the song was dull. The reason the song was released on Rubber Soul was that that album was one song short, and with the Christmas deadline looming, the Beatles chose to release 'Wait' instead of recording a new composition."
That doesn't really make you want to rush right out and but the album, does it?
|
Sorry, one song doesn't discredit a whole album.
Quote:
A huge difference on Revolver is Ken Townsend doing the engineering (also did it for Sgt. Pepper's) which was incredibly groundbreaking work. Backwards guitar, automatic double tracking, backmasking and closemiking, etc. Also, The sound is much more a mix of Rock and Pop, with McCartney being influenced by Motown and Lennon bringing Psychedelic sounds to the masses (Tomorrow Never Knows)
Rubber Soul did none of that.
There's my argument. Revolver was when the Beatles began to change their styles.
|
Wayfarer basically said all that needed to be said. The only thing I'd add is the Byrds/Bob Dylan influence that began to appear there is something that you wouldn't have found on Help! either. Also I'd consider The Word a psychedelic song and even if you don't you can't deny the effect Lennon used on the piano in it was extremely influential in the genre.