Music Banter - View Single Post - The Beatles
Thread: The Beatles
View Single Post
Old 12-27-2007, 11:37 AM   #453 (permalink)
fanofthefab4
Groupie
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 23
Thumbs down

Quote:
Originally Posted by Music Man View Post
"So what? This means he wasn't an important member of the band HOW?"

Ringo's musical contribution to the band was insignificant. Of the many studio albums the Beatles released, he only wrote one song that can be called completely his own, and it was definitely one of the weaker songs that ever appeared on any Beatle album.

"Well thats what drummers do. John and Paul may have given him a direction or an idea of what they wanted, but he still wrote his own parts."

No, he rarely wrote his own parts. Paul and John usually told him how and what to play on each song, and he complied.

"Of the only songs Ringo didn't play on, which is a very ridiculous few, it was either because he wasn't available and Paul, John or George wanted to finish their songs quickly or because he walked out on the band on a few occasions due to the tensions between him and the other members."

One of the top members on the Apple Studios team that recorded the Beatles, revealed that on several occasions, Paul had to go in and replace Ringo's sub-par drum tracks with his own.

An interviewer once asked John Lennon if he thought Ringo was the best drummer in the world. A somewhat shocked and amused John promptly replied that Ringo wasn't even the best drummer in the Beatles!

In all the years and all the songs Ringo recorded with the Beatles, he only played ONE drum solo on ONE song! That was in the song "The End" on their final album--"Abbey Road". Not to mention that there was nothing special about the solo.

ONE mediocre song and ONE average at best drum solo in all those years and recordings with the Beatles. NOT impressive!
John Lennon *NEVER* said this garbage about Ringo's drumming! Go look up a great UK John Lennon fan site,You Are The Plastic Ono Band and read his September 1971 interview at the ST.Regis Hotel and John was asked what he thought about Ringo's drumming and he said that Jim Keltner is a little bit more technical but he feels that Ringo is still one of the best rock drummers! John used Ringo on his first brilliant solo album,John Lennon Plastic Ono Band and he could have gotten any other rock drummer and most would have jumped at the chance to play the drums on a John Lennon album! And Ringo's drumming is very good on this album just like it is on all of The Beatles albums!

John also said Ringo had the best back beat drumming in rock! And Ringo's drumming is great on an early Beatles song Thank You Girl especially at the end it's noticeable,and on Tomorrow Never Knows,Rain which he says is his best work,Strawberry Fields Forever,A Day In The Life which George Martin says it was Ringo's idea to use tom toms giving the song a unique percussion sound,which Phil Collins says is so complicated that he and no other drummer could repeat it! His druming is great on The White album and Abbey Road too including the End solo!

Also Ringo was the drummer for 5 years for the most successful Liverpool group at the time Rory Storm And The Hurricanes and The Beatles and George Martin wanted Pete Best out because he wasn't as good or experienced as Ringo and they wanted to make it big and go up not down so they got a very good successful drummer,Ringo Starr! Also Mark Lewisohn says in his excellent thorough detailed music diary of The Beatles, The Beatles Recording Sessions,where many of their recording engineers and tape operators were interviewed and it truly demonstrates just how creative,innovative and prolific THe Beatles were especially John and Paul,he says in all of the 100's of hours of session tapes,where John and Paul as the perfectionists they were would do everything over so many times,Ringo only made a few mistakes. Mark says Ringo's drumming was remarkably consistent and excellent from 1962-1970.

Last edited by fanofthefab4; 12-27-2007 at 12:15 PM.
fanofthefab4 is offline   Reply With Quote