Quote:
Originally Posted by Wayfarer
As far as solo material goes:
The Madcap Laughs > Barrett > On An Island > David Gilmour > About Face
As far as Pink Floyd goes:
The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn > Animals > Dark Side Of The Moon > Meddle, and so on...with the two David-lead albums coming in last, along with "The Final Cut".
Additionally, I'd say tracks 1-3 & 5 on "The Early Singles" are up there with Piper as the best material the band ever recorded. Oh, and "Vegetable Man", of course. Wish they included that song on Saucerful.
But yeah, Syd wins, IMO.
|
I personally think On An island is Dave's worse solo album but big points for Animals so high up. New favourite poster title has been reclaimed!