Music Banter - View Single Post

jmon · 04-08-2008, 09:49 PM

Mr. Dave-

This really isn't about OLP. Who really cares. The point was not that it was OLP. The point was much broader than that. And as far as the antics of OLP with set fans and whatnot...it happens, not just in small bands, but some of big band you worship too. As long as you enjoy the music who the F* cares. You do make a valid point though. This will probably bring more attention to the bands whose songs are featured on Idol.

So I guess the question is this...given the choice what would you do?

You either
A. Are a top 10 contestant on American Idol and might win, whatever...

or

B. You play club and bar after bar until you make it. Someone from a label finds you...whatever.

Does one gain you more respect from other musicians?
Does one make you a better musician?

And you are right and wrong Swim...you may not be in it for the money....but many many people in the industry or trying to break the industry ARE.

04-08-2008, 09:49 PM	#8 (permalink)
jmon Groupie Join Date: Apr 2008 Posts: 4	Mr. Dave- This really isn't about OLP. Who really cares. The point was not that it was OLP. The point was much broader than that. And as far as the antics of OLP with set fans and whatnot...it happens, not just in small bands, but some of big band you worship too. As long as you enjoy the music who the F* cares. You do make a valid point though. This will probably bring more attention to the bands whose songs are featured on Idol. So I guess the question is this...given the choice what would you do? You either A. Are a top 10 contestant on American Idol and might win, whatever... or B. You play club and bar after bar until you make it. Someone from a label finds you...whatever. Does one gain you more respect from other musicians? Does one make you a better musician? And you are right and wrong Swim...you may not be in it for the money....but many many people in the industry or trying to break the industry ARE.