I remember seeing a thread when I first joined that was about covers. Problem is that it was only a list and didn't really compare the original to the cover. I'd like to have a chance to discuss how the cover affected the original. Did the cover artist stay true to the original? Maybe change it and somehow improve it? Did they rape it and leave it for dead in a ditch? With the wonderful ability to embed Youtube videos, I think we can enjoy this thread even more.
First, I'd like to talk about Breadfan.
Originally by Budgie in 1973.
Covered by Metallica in 1988
I think that Metallica stayed true to the song. The Metallica version has a slightly faster feel and Hetfield's vocals are a bit rougher, but these are expected with the nature of Metallica's sound at the time.
Next up is Hurt.
Originally by Nine Inch Nails in 1994
(not an official video. This is the only studio version I could find on youtube)
Covered by Johnny Cash in 2002
My opinion is that Johnny Cash improved the song and added a level of depth and passion. I'm not saying that it is necessarily better, but Cash took it and made it his. He didn't settle for making a Nine Inch Nails song, he only used their words and beat and gave the song a new life.
Last up is American Pie.
Originally by Don McClean in 1971.
(its best to not watch the crappy video when listening to the song.)
Covered by
Madonna (I think I just threw up a little) in 2000
I'd like to say that the Madonna version had some good qualities but I just can't. Its no shock that I'm not a fan of this version. I can't think of anyone that really is. It was a well done folk rock song in its original form, but Madonna turned it into a horrible pop/dance song.