Music Banter - View Single Post - The Case For/ The Case Against..
View Single Post
Old 06-11-2008, 08:21 AM   #8 (permalink)
Rainard Jalen
Music Addict
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 2,219
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Piss Me Off View Post
Case Against

Well it's Nirvana's worst studio album. Gone is the rough, grunge inspired sound of Bleach and in comes a more polished sound which doesn't suit them. Watching live footage of them, even in the Nevermind period, they played loud and sloppily with lots of feedback and distortion and they rocked, all of this is absent in the more user-friendly sheen of this album.
Quite a bit of filler as well, there's nothing wrong with songs like Stay Away and Lounge Act but they're hardly interesting. You could say the same of Bleach but but then its all with that sludgy sound which i prefer far more.
Crikey, Lucas. Where do I start?

1: The polished sound; this sound was always the sound that Nirvana were supposed to have. Cobain's main talent lied in the fact that he could write AWESOME pop punk songs and was a brilliant melodist. He didn't have any great artistic merits beyond that. These were his latent skills that were desperate to be awoken. The band as such was the perfect blueprint for a pop success, and thus the well-produced tight sound was always bound to be theirs. They were nothing as a sludge band. So what if there was lots of "sloppy feedback and distortion" or whatever - they didn't have the songs, and there was little to distinguish them from any of the other bands doing exactly the same thing. Nevermind is the album where they find their own sound and become something worth mentioning.

2: User friendly; of course it's user friendly, it's a pop album. It's aims are totally different to that of Bleach. Bleach was neither user friendly nor worth an awful lot to anybody else. At least in being user friendly they were actually something worth mentioning - something we'd actually be discussing 17 years on (for sure as hell we wouldn't be discussing Bleach Nirvana). Now, I do understand that what you mean is that at gigs they still had a more sludgy, messy sound. But then, I don't think studio recordings and gigs ought to sound the same anyway. Studios give the opportunity to do something different with your sound, and the fact is that everything on Nevermind sounds sharp, refined and good.

3: I don't agree that there is a lot of filler on this album. There are maximally two possible filler tracks: "Stay Away", and "Territorial Pissings", both of which succeed at being listenable and unnecessary to skip. Lounge Act is an excellent song. Go listen to it!




In sum, I do personally prefer In Utero over Nevermind but I'm amazed that people will still try to say that a nothing album of junk like Bleach could be a better studio recording than this, in all its songwriting excellence.
Rainard Jalen is offline   Reply With Quote